Cardiovascular effects in patrol officers are associated with fine particulate matter from brake wear and engine emissions
© Riediker et al. 2004
Received: 24 August 2004
Accepted: 09 December 2004
Published: 09 December 2004
Exposure to fine particulate matter air pollutants (PM2.5) affects heart rate variability parameters, and levels of serum proteins associated with inflammation, hemostasis and thrombosis. This study investigated sources potentially responsible for cardiovascular and hematological effects in highway patrol troopers.
Nine healthy young non-smoking male troopers working from 3 PM to midnight were studied on four consecutive days during their shift and the following night. Sources of in-vehicle PM2.5 were identified with variance-maximizing rotational principal factor analysis of PM2.5-components and associated pollutants. Two source models were calculated. Sources of in-vehicle PM2.5 identified were 1) crustal material, 2) wear of steel automotive components, 3) gasoline combustion, 4) speed-changing traffic with engine emissions and brake wear. In one model, sources 1 and 2 collapsed to a single source. Source factors scores were compared to cardiac and blood parameters measured ten and fifteen hours, respectively, after each shift. The "speed-change" factor was significantly associated with mean heart cycle length (MCL, +7% per standard deviation increase in the factor score), heart rate variability (+16%), supraventricular ectopic beats (+39%), % neutrophils (+7%), % lymphocytes (-10%), red blood cell volume MCV (+1%), von Willebrand Factor (+9%), blood urea nitrogen (+7%), and protein C (-11%). The "crustal" factor (but not the "collapsed" source) was associated with MCL (+3%) and serum uric acid concentrations (+5%). Controlling for potential confounders had little influence on the effect estimates.
PM2.5 originating from speed-changing traffic modulates the autonomic control of the heart rhythm, increases the frequency of premature supraventricular beats and elicits pro-inflammatory and pro-thrombotic responses in healthy young men.
List of abbreviations
- HRV :
heart rate variability
- MCL :
mean cycle length of normal R-R intervals
- MCV :
mean red blood cell volume
- PNN50 :
percentage of normal R-R interval differences greater than 50 msec
- SDNN :
standard deviation of normal R-R intervals
- VWF :
von Willebrand factor
Exposure to fine particulate matter (PM2.5) in the ambient air increases daily deaths  and hospitalization for cardiovascular diseases  in the U.S. and throughout the world  with most effects within one day after exposure. It is estimated that 800,000 excess deaths worldwide each year may be attributable to particulate matter air pollution , possibly secondary to myocardial infarction , life-threatening arrhythmias  or heart failure, as reviewed in a recent American Heart Association scientific statement . Yet, the underlying pathophysiological mechanisms that link PM2.5 and cardiopulmonary mortality are poorly understood.
Particles of motor vehicle origin appear to be especially potent with regard to increased mortality [8, 9] and hospital admissions due to cardiovascular diseases . Vehicles represent a microenvironment with potentially high exposure to air pollutants from mobile sources. We previously showed that occupational in-vehicle PM2.5 exposure to North Carolina Highway Patrol troopers was associated with changes in cardiac parameters, blood proteins associated with inflammation, hemostasis and thrombosis, and increased red blood cell volume (MCV) 10 to 15 hours after completing their shift . These findings were little affected by potential confounders. Controlling for estimates of occupational stress even slightly improved the strength of association with some cardiac parameters. In this paper, we investigated how these health endpoints were associated with specific sources of PM2.5.
Data from nine male non-smoking troopers (8 Caucasian, 1 African-American) were used for the analysis: ten participated, one was excluded due to very high numbers of ectopic beats and high serum cholesterol. This left a total of 36 person-days with valid health data. Their age ranged from 23 to 30 years (mean 27.3 years), their weight from 74 to 102 kg (87 kg), their height from 168 to 191 cm (179 cm), and their body mass index from 24 to 31 kg/m2 (27 kg/m2). All were in excellent physical condition.
Exposure inside the cars and source identification
Components included in the analysis In-vehicle concentrations of the elemental components of PM2.5 and gaseous co-pollutants included in the analysis (n = 36 samples): Arithmetic average, standard deviation and correlation (Spearman-Rho) to PM2.5Mass and PM2.5Lightscatter. *) p < 0.05.
Correlation to PM2.5Mass
Correlation to PM2.5Lightscatter
Aluminum (Al, ng/m3)
Silicon (Si, ng/m3)
Sulfur (S, ng/m3)
Calcium (Ca, ng/m3)
Titanium (Ti, ng/m3)
Chromium (Cr, ng/m3)
Iron (Fe, ng/m3)
Copper (Cu, ng/m3)
Selenium (Se, ng/m3)
Tungsten (W, ng/m3)
Source model characteristics Characteristics of the two models and their factors of the principal factor analysis and their associations with the two PM2.5-measures: Model A includes all components shown in Table 1, Model B excludes Ca, Cr, Se and W.
Number of exposure variables included
Total variance explained
Correlation with PM2.5Mass (R2)
Correlation with PM2.5Lightscatter (R2)
Factor 1 "crustal"
Factor 2 "steel wear"
Factor 3 "gasoline"
Factor 4 "speed-change"
Factor 1 "road surface"
Factor 2 "gasoline"
Factor 3 "speed-change"
Sum of squares of factor loadings
Proportion of total variance
Slopea of correlation with PM2.5Mass
p = 0.0006
p < 0.0001
p = 0.003
p < 0.0001
p < 0.0001
p = 0.002
p = 0.002
Slopea of correlation with PM2.5Lightscatter
p = 0.6 (n.s.)
p = 0.01
p = 0.004
p < 0.0001
p = 0.15 (n.s.)
p = 0.026
p < 0.0001
Source model B was calculated using only elements that were clearly correlated to PM2.5 and with the majority of data more than 3 sigma above background noise (i.e., without Ca, Cr, Se and W). Three source factors were identified (Figure 1B and Table 2). Factor 1 was dominated by silicon, aluminum, titanium and iron (named "road surface"); factor 2 by benzene and carbon monoxide ("gasoline"); and factor 3 by copper, sulfur and aldehydes ("speed-change").
The factor "road surface" of Model B was significantly correlated to the factors "crustal" and "steel wear" of Model A (R = 0.80 and 0.64, respectively). Factor "gasoline" of A was correlated to factor "gasoline" of B (R = 0.80); and factor "speed-change" of A to "speed-change" of B (R = 0.91). In contrast, the source factors within each model were completely uncorrelated (R < 0.09).
Health endpoints associated with sources
Strong heteroscedasticity (i.e., an indication for a violation of the underlying statistical assumptions) was evidenced in the residual analysis of the models for red blood cell count, hematocrit and hemoglobin (which were significantly associated with the "speed-change" factor). However, every attempt to remove the heteroscedasticity by adjusting the variance-covariance structure also completely removed the significance of these associations.
Control for potential confounders
The associations observed between factors and health parameters were tested for the following potential confounders: Temperature, relative humidity, the number of law-enforcement activities during the shift (as estimate of workload) and the average speed during the shift. Controlling for these confounders had no visible effect on most effect estimates of the "crustal" and the "speed-change" factor, and the associated health parameters. However, in Models A and B, including these confounders altered the effect estimates with blood urea nitrogen and vWF, especially including all confounders together into the models lowered the effect estimates for the source factor "speed-change" by about one fifth and the confidence interval included zero. In Model A, the estimate for PNN50 was not altered by any of the confounders, but including all confounders into the same model widened the confidence interval to include zero.
We previously reported that in-vehicle exposure to PM2.5 was associated with increases in markers of inflammation and coagulation, and modulations of heart rate variability in Highway Patrol troopers . Here we demonstrate that most health endpoints were associated to a PM2.5 source factor that reflects speed-changing traffic conditions (dominated by copper, aldehydes and sulfur). Under such driving conditions, copper reflects wear of brakes, aldehydes reflect emissions from accelerating vehicles and sulfur reflects secondary aerosols and possibly diesel combustion products.
In Model A, four principal factors of PM2.5-exposure inside the patrol cars were identified. Their loadings suggest the main in-vehicle sources of PM2.5. Factor 1 reflects exposure to crustal material from the soils in the study region and the road surface ("crustal" factor). Factor 2 represents wear and tear of mechanical automotive parts, mostly chrome-titanium steels ("steel wear" factor). Factor 3 represents components derived from gasoline combustion ("gasoline factor"). Finally, factor 4 is characterized by components expected from speed-changing traffic ("speed-change" factor): copper from brakes  and aldehydes from engine emissions . Note that photochemical processes  are an unlikely source for this factor, since urban background and roadside levels near free-flowing traffic were much lower than in-vehicle levels . The source of the high sulfur loading is unclear. Diesel combustion of accelerating trucks would be a plausible source candidate. However, sulfur is ubiquitous on secondary urban aerosols. It was the most concentrated element on PM2.5 in the study . This prevents the identification of local sources with sulfur as a tracer. A cautious interpretation might be that factor 4 reflects particles from speed-changing traffic mixed with secondary urban particles; a mixture expected on roads in an urban-sprawl area like Raleigh.
Model B proposes only three sources. However, they correspond in principle to the sources from Model A, except that the factors " crustal" and "steel wear" seem to be collapsed into a single source factor "road surface". This notion is supported by the good correlation between the corresponding factors.
The average PM2.5 concentration of ca. 23 μg/m3 inside the vehicles was at a moderate level compared to the 24-hour National Ambient Air Quality Standard for PM2.5 of 65 μg/m3. The two methods used to measure PM2.5 were highly correlated. The differences of their correlations to the components (Table 1) and to the source factors (Tables 2) reflect the fact that two different methods were used to assess the particle mass : PM2.5Lightscatter reflects mostly accumulation mode particles (0.2 to 2 μm), whereas PM2.5Mass includes some coarse dust including fine sand.
The "speed-change" factor (Models A and B) was significantly associated with increased percentage of neutrophil leucocytes in the circulating blood, with decreased percentage of lymphocytes, and with changes in markers of endothelial activation and hemostasis. Endothelial cells are a major storage site for von Willebrand factor , and plasma levels of vWF serve as markers for endothelial activation . Protein C is an antithrombotic agent, it is activated on the endothelium and reduced in the blood after inflammatory stimulation due to protein C consumption . Consequently, endothelial cells may be involved in both inflammatory and coagulatory responses to traffic particles. Blood urea nitrogen was also associated with the "speed-change" factor. This finding would be consistent with the postulated inflammation since blood urea nitrogen increases several hours after an inflammatory stimulus (pig model) . Blood urea nitrogen and vWF lost significance when controlled for all potential confounders together, although the effect estimates were not much changed. It should be noted that including this many confounders into a model with a relatively small number of samples reduces the strength of the statistics considerably.
The "speed-change" factor was significantly associated with changes in MCV (independent of osmolality) and similar to the association for PM2.5Lightscatter with MCV reported earlier . The present analysis suggests that particles originating from speed-changing traffic are an important source of this association with circulating red blood cell mean volume (while other red blood cell indices were not affected). This is consistent with in-vitro blood experiments, where high concentrations of particles caused dose-dependent hemolysis, which was explained by oxidative damage to the membranes . Note that MCV increases with increasing doses of hemolytic chemicals . Future studies might answer the question whether particle-induced oxidative stress caused the association observed between MCV and the "speed-change" source factor.
The heart beat interval MCL increased in association with the "crustal" factor and the "speed-change" factor. Additionally, the "speed-change" factor was associated with significant increases in heart rate variability (SDNN and PNN50) and frequency of supraventricular ectopic beats. This cardiac response suggests increased vagal tone mostly in response to "speed-change" traffic particles. Fluctuations in autonomic tone have been associated with the triggering of atrial arrhythmias . Such fluctuations might also help explain the reported association between air pollution exposure and increases in arrhythmias in patients with an implanted cardioverter defibrillator .
The concentrations of particles and components in this study were low. Direct systemic effects seem therefore unlikely. However, the proposed endothelial activation could provide a link to pathological processes and the associated increase in cardiovascular morbidity and mortality , as follows: Once particles are deposited on the surfaces of the airways or alveoli, toxic products can quickly leach out or be produced on the surface of the particles. Given the small volume of surface liquid, this can result in high local concentrations. Copper and other transition metals can cause oxidative stress  and have been associated with inflammatory lung injury in human subjects  as well as airway epithelial cell injury in vitro . This oxidative stress might induce responses in the adjacent cells. In the alveolar region, the distance to the capillary endothelium is about 100 nanometers. Liberation of pro-thrombotic and pro-inflammatory mediators are well-described consequences of oxidative stress to endothelial and other cells . Inflammatory stimuli also might induce a vagal response . The components copper, sulfur and aldehydes dominated the "speed-change" factor. They seem to merit further attention in future targeted studies on particle toxicology.
Surprisingly, the "steel wear" factor of Model A was not associated to any inflammatory markers, although metal content of particles has been reported to be associated with inflammatory processes [24, 25, 28]. It would be interesting to study such wear particles with regard to size and solubility of metals.
One limitation of this study is the fact that only the association between the mean exposure during the evening shift and the response on the following morning was studied. This design ensured that potential diurnal variations of exposure and health parameters could not mimic a dose-response association, and that the exposure inside the cars was followed by a long unexposed resting period. However, it cannot be excluded that exposures and follow-up at other times of the day could have resulted in different dose-response estimates. Another limitation is the study population, since the troopers were a homogenous group of young, healthy, non-smoking people in excellent physical condition. Consequently, it is possible that the relative response such as the %-increase of inflammatory blood components or ectopic heart beats might be different in the troopers as compared to what could be expected in the general population or in individuals with elevated cardiovascular risks that have higher baseline levels. A final limitation is that the source factor "speed-changing" traffic does not represent a single source but rather a combination of closely related sources such as break wear and engine exhaust products. Answering the question, which of these sub-sources was causing the effects, would require a larger number of subjects or targeted toxicological studies.
Fine particulate matter from vehicular traffic may activate one or more signaling pathways that cause pro-inflammatory, pro-thrombotic and hemolytic responses in healthy young men. The changes in the heart rate variability suggest an increased parasympathetic input to the heart with an associated increase in arrhythmic events, possibly in response to mild lung inflammation. These findings suggest the hypothesis that pollutants emitted during speed-changing traffic conditions negatively impact the health risks of professional or otherwise frequent vehicle drivers and passengers, or other people exposed to these particles. A long-term cardiovascular risk to the troopers can not be excluded, especially when considering the reported increase in myocardial infarction among professional drivers  and the increase in mortality among people living near major roadways . These findings might be helpful for designing targeted studies in the future that investigate causative pathways for health effects of PM2.5.
The study was conducted in fall 2001 in Wake County, North Carolina, USA. The Institutional Review Board of the UNC School of Medicine approved the study. All subjects gave informed written consent. Data from nine non-smoking male Highway Patrol troopers were analyzed. Each was monitored from Monday to Thursday while working the 3 PM to midnight shift. The troopers refrained from alcohol, caffeine and any medication from 24 hours before the start until the end of their participation. Each patrol car was equipped with air quality monitors to measure their exposure during the shift as described earlier . Particle mass was assessed by two methods: PM2.5Mass by weighing filters; and PM2.5Lightscatter based on lightscattering. "Aldehydes" refers to the sum of formaldehyde, acetaldehyde, acrolein, propionaldehyde, crotonaldehyde, n-butyraldehyde, benzaldehyde, valeraldehyde, tolualdehyde, hexanaldehyde, and 2,5-dimethylbenzaldehyde.
Health parameters were assessed by ambulatory electrocardiography during the work shift and the subsequent sleep phase, and by analyses of peripheral blood samples drawn 15 hours after completion of the shift as described earlier . Heart rate variability (HRV) measures in the time and frequency domain were calculated for resting periods before and after the shift, and in the morning after awakening. For the analysis presented, only data from the morning resting period were used. Parameters included the mean cycle length of normal R-R intervals (MCL), the standard deviation of normal R-R intervals (SDNN) and the percentage of normal R-R interval differences greater than 50 msec (PNN50), low frequency (0.04 to 0.15 Hz), high-frequency power (0.15 to 0.40 Hz) and the ratio of low to high frequency power. The number of ventricular and supraventricular ectopic beats were counted during the shift and the contiguous night.
Blood was collected from an antecubital vein and analyzed . The analyses included uric acid, blood urea nitrogen, gamma glutamyl transpeptidase, white blood cell count, red blood cell count, hematocrit, hemoglobin, mean red blood cell volume (MCV), neutrophils (count and %), lymphocytes (count and %), C-reactive protein, plasminogen, plasminogen activator inhibitor type 1, von Willebrand factor (vWF), endothelin-1, protein C, and interleukin-6.
Spearman correlations were calculated using SYSTAT 10 (Systat Software Inc., Richmond, CA), all other statistics using S-Plus 6.1 for Windows (Mathsoft Inc., Cambridge, MA).
For classification of the exposure by potential sources, a principal factor analysis (factanal procedure) with variance-maximizing rotation  was conducted after controlling for outliers and missing data. One silicon value measured inside a patrol car was an outlier, possibly due to a grain of sand. This value was replaced by an estimate based on the aluminum level (Al was highly correlated to Si). Missing data (3 values of benzene and 2 of aldehydes) were replaced by the mean of the component concerned. For data below the propagated detection limit, machine-readouts were used. Factors with sum of squares of factor loadings larger than one were retained. The number of exposure variables included was limited to obtain stable results with this relatively small number of individual samples: only variables with a clear association to PM2.5 and with reasonable data quality were used. In a first model ("Model A") PM2.5-components, that were significantly correlated to either PM2.5Mass or PM2.5Lightscatter (Spearman Rho > 0.3), and gaseous co-pollutants, that were strongly and significantly correlated (Rho > 0.5) were included in the source factor analysis if at least 75% of the data were above reporting limit. A second model ("Model B") was calculated to assess the robustness of the source factor modeling and the associated health effects. Model B excluded PM2.5-components from the analysis with large uncertainties (Cr, Se and W with over 50% of data less than 3 sigma above background noise) or with weak correlation to PM2.5 (Ca).
Mixed effects regression models with restricted maximum-likelihood estimation, exposure factors as fixed effects and an unconstrained variance-covariance structure with subjects as grouping factors were used to investigate the associations between exposure and health endpoints [11, 31]. Potential confounders were controlled for by including them into the models. Model testing included alternative, constrained variance-covariance structures (first-order autoregressive as well as linear and exponential spatial designs), and adding exposure factors to the random effects structure. None of these attempts improved the overall quality of the models judged by the Akaike Information Criterion, analysis of variance and residual analysis (distribution and autocorrelation). Consequently, only results from unconstrained models are reported.
We thank the North Carolina State Highway Patrol for enabling this study, and the support staff of NCSHP, UNC Chapel Hill, U.S. EPA, all contractors, and the participating troopers.
This work has been funded by The United States Environmental Protection Agency under Cooperative Agreements CR-824195 and CR-829522 to the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, by contract 68-D-00-206 to ManTech Environmental Technology and by the Swiss National Science Foundation to MR. It has been subjected to Agency review and approved for publication but does not necessarily reflect EPA policy.
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.