Skip to main content

Table 3 Tiered Testing Strategy to support the HARN IATA. Recommended methods and models to address each IATA decision node are set-out according to the appropriate tier of testing.

From: Grouping MWCNTs based on their similar potential to cause pulmonary hazard after inhalation: a case-study

Can HARN deposit in the distal lung?

Does the HARN dissolve very slowly in lung lining fluid (pH7.4)?

Does the HARN dissolve very slowly in lysosomal fluid (pH4.5)?

Is HARN length > 5 µm?

Is HARN rigid and maintain a needle-like morphology?

Does HARN cause frustrated phagocytosis?

Tier 1

Review existing data sets

Estimation of aerodynamic diameter from diameter and density of HARN

Batch dissolution test or dissolution in continuous flow system in lung lining fluid

Batch dissolution test or dissolution in continuous flow system in lysosomal fluid

Length distribution profile from TEM/SEM images

Mean diameter of HARN from TEM/SEM. Include supporting images

Inflammasome activation in macrophage exposed to HARN: IL-1β release

Tier 2

Review existing data sets

Measurement of mass median aerodynamic diameter (MMAD) from airborne dispersion of material

 

Durability in cellular systems

HARN length measurement from airborne dispersion of material from TEM/SEM images

HARN size measurement from airborne dispersion of material from TEM/SEM images. Include supporting images

In vitro granuloma formation

Tier 3

Review existing data sets

Quantification of lung deposition during in vivo inhalation studies

Quantification of lung burden and clearance kinetics during in vivo inhalation studies

  

Fibre rigidity of HARN demonstrated by morphological assessment and/or size measurements after incubation with macrophages in vitro or in vivo

Evidence of frustrated phagocytosis and granuloma formation from in vivo exposure (OECD GD 39)