- Open Access
Cytokine responses of human lung cells (BEAS-2B) treated with micron-sized and nanoparticles of metal oxides compared to soil dusts
Particle and Fibre Toxicology volume 4, Article number: 2 (2007)
The induction of cytokines by airway cells in vitro has been widely used to assess the effects of ambient and occupational particles. This study measured cytotoxicity and the release of the proinflammatory cytokines IL-6 and IL-8 by human bronchial epithelial cells treated with manufactured nano- and micron-sized particles of Al2O3, CeO2, Fe2O3, NiO, SiO2, and TiO2, with soil-derived particles from fugitive dust sources, and with the positive controls LPS, TNF-α, and VOSO4.
The nano-sized particles were not consistently more potent than an equal mass of micron-sized particles of the same nominal composition for the induction of IL-6 and IL-8 secretion in the in vitro models used in this study. The manufactured pure oxides were much less potent than natural PM2.5 particles derived from soil dust, and the cells were highly responsive to the positive controls. The nano-sized particles in the media caused artifacts in the measurement of IL-6 by ELISA due to adsorption of the cytokine on the high-surface-area particles. The potency for inducing IL-6 secretion by BEAS-2B cells did not correlate with the generation of reactive oxygen species in cell-free media.
Direct comparisons of manufactured metal oxide nanoparticles and previously studied types of particles and surrogate proinflammatory agonists showed that the metal oxide particles have low potency to induce IL-6 secretion in BEAS-2B cells. Particle artifacts from non-biological effects need to be considered in experiments of this type, and the limitations inherent in cell culture studies must be considered when interpreting in vitro results. This study suggests that manufactured metal oxide nanoparticles are not highly toxic to lung cells compared to environmental particles.
Nanosized particles of many different metal and ceramic oxides are currently being commercially manufactured for applications that include high-performance composite materials, abrasives in semiconductor manufacturing, photochemically active or wavelength selective surface coatings, process catalysts, electronic components, and cosmetics. Particles smaller than 100 nm of carbon, silica and titanium dioxide are currently sold as bulk chemicals, and many more nanoparticle types will be produced in tonnage quantities as manufacturing technology improves and prices are reduced. Increased production volume on nanomaterials will lead to increased human and environmental exposure from normal use, fugitive emissions, accidental spills, and disposal of materials after use. Current environmental laws and occupational health guidelines are based on the nominal chemical composition and seldom specify special standards for ultrafine or nano-sized particles. The potential occupational health and environmental effects of these nano-sized powders are a public policy concern, and this research was funded by a program addressing toxicology of manufactured nanomaterials.
Particle-induced tissue inflammation has been proposed as a central process connecting inhaled particles with adverse health effects . The onset and resolution of inflammation is regulated by cytokines, a class of signaling molecules associated with many processes including cell growth and differentiation, physiological responses of tissues, and recruitment of macrophages and other mobile cells to specific sites [2–4]. Cytokine assays are widely used in studies of lung cell responses to particles and other pollutants . Much of the recent in vitro particle toxicology research has used ELISA assays to measure the cytokines IL-6 [6–8], IL-8 [9–11], and TNF-α [12–14] in cell cultures exposed to different types of solid particles.
There is increasing evidence suggesting that redox-active transition metals associated with particles can induce pro-inflammatory responses in lung cells [9, 15–18]. Reactive oxygen species (ROS) is a non-specific term that includes both radicals (OH•, O2 -•) and non-radicals (H2O2). There is evidence for both extracellular and intracellular reactions leading to ROS formation in particle-treated in vitro systems [14, 19, 20]. Extracellular generation of ROS has been proposed as a mechanism by which particles may stimulate cell-surface receptors. The oxidation of the probe dichlorodihydrofluorescein (DCFH) to the fluorescent compound 2' – 7' dichlorofluorescein (DCF) is a common way of measuring ROS in cell cultures [21–23]. The DCFH assay measures multiple species including RO2•, RO•, OH•, HOCl, ONOO-  and the products of metal-catalyzed reactions involving peroxide.
Animal studies with carbon black and titanium dioxide particles reported that particles smaller than 30 nm have a greater ability to induce lung inflammation than larger particles with the same nominal composition [25, 26]. Both Donaldson  and Oberdörster  concluded in reviews that ultrafine particles of low-solubility, low-toxicity materials are more inflammogenic in the rat lung than larger particles from the same material, and hypothesized that the effects are related to surface area and involve oxidative stress.
Although many studies have investigated particle-induced cytokine responses in vitro, it is difficult to make quantitative comparisons of various particle types from the literature. Comparisons are confounded by differences between studies in the biological model tested (rodent or human macrophages or epithelial cells, immortalized or normal cells), the experimental protocol (concentration, duration), and endpoints reported (cell death, cytokine secretion, changes in mRNA). This study used a consistent set of in vitro experimental protocols to study six different compositions of manufactured particles that are commercially available as both nano- and micron sized powders. We used a nominal diameter of 30 nm as the definition of nanosized particles and compared these to particles larger than 1 μm diameter of the same nominal chemical composition. We also compared the manufactured metal and ceramic oxide particles to soil-derived dusts [29, 30] and to the positive controls lipopolysaccharide (LPS), tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-α) and soluble vanadium (VOSO4). The objectives were to: 1) characterize the proinflammatory cytokine response of human lung epithelial cells treated in vitro with manufactured metal and ceramic oxide particles, 2) compare nano-sized and micron-sized particle pairs for several different oxides, and 3) compare the cytokine responses induced by manufactured oxide particles to the responses to natural minerals and surface-derived fugitive dusts.
The particles used in this study are described in Table 1. The surface-mean particle size calculated from nitrogen adsorption area measurement was close to the nominal particle size furnished by the vendor except for the supermicron particles of NiO. The adsorbtion surface area was much greater than the geometrical surface for the nominal diameter indicating that the NiO particles either are aggregates or have internal porosity. The natural dusts, prepared by resuspension and aerodynamic separation with an upper size cutpoint of <3 μm, also have high surface area indicating that the nominal PM2.5 dust had a broad size distribution and contained significant amounts of smaller particles.
The elemental compositions of the natural soil-derived dusts as measured by x-ray fluorescence are dominated by the crustal elements, Al, Si, Ca, Mg, and Ti. The endotoxin content, organic carbon content (functionally defined as the carbon that is volatile in He atmosphere at temperature steps < 550°C) and the elemental carbon content (carbon that is removed in 2% O2/98% He at temperatures from 550 to 800°C) are listed in Table 2.
Cell viability was evaluated to insure that low levels of cytokine secretion were not caused by cell death during the treatment period. Figure 1 shows the assay results for the highest treatment concentration (53 μg/cm2) of particles and for the concentrations of positive controls listed in Table 1. Only the VOSO4 positive control caused more than 20% loss of cell viability at the 24-h time point, as measured by the mitochondrial reduction of WST-8.
The release of IL-6 by the immortalized cell line BEAS-2B in response to treatment with pairs of nano- and micron-sized particles is shown in Figure 2. Experiments were conducted in both KGM (2a and 2c) and LHC-9 media (2b and 2d). Graphs in 2a and 2b show typical results obtained from single experiments. Presented in this way the data suggest that the metal oxide particles induce small increases in IL-6 secretion, but that the nano-sized particles are not consistently more potent than the larger particles in each pair. Graphs 2c and 2d present the data in 2a and 2b merged with a followup experiment and also present the results from positive controls run in both experiments. The agreement between the two experiments is good, but the larger data set suggests that the IL-6 response to all the pure oxide manufactured particles is small compared to the positive controls. The pure oxides were also compared to kaolin (pottery clay), and Min-U-Sil (commercial mechanically ground crystalline silica), and neither of these particle was highly potent for inducing IL-6 secretion. The experiments in Figure 2 were conducted 5.3 and 53 μg/cm2 particle concentration in media with 0.1% BSA added. Data shown are for the high particle treatment concentration and for the positive control concentrations in Table 1. Similar small responses to pure oxide particles compared to positive controls were seen at the low dose and in experiments with as-formulated media.
To further characterize the response of BEAS-2B cells to the manufactured oxide particles we conducted a separate set of experiments where each cell culture plate contained two of the nano-sized particle types, soil-derived particles from three different sites, and positive controls. Figure 3 shows the merged results of five independent experiments conducted in KGM and LHC-9 media with particles at 53 μg/cm2 and with the positive controls at concentrations listed in Table 1. The manufactured metal and ceramic oxide particles were less potent for the induction of IL-6 release than an equal mass concentration of three different soil-derived dusts. The LPS, TNF-a, and soluble vanadium are positive controls that show that the BEAS-2B cells are capable of producing IL-6 under the experimental conditions. The DD, JE, and MC samples are PM2.5-enriched dusts prepared from surface soil samples, and are the same materials used in our previous studies of cytokine response in epithelial cells exposed to atmospheric fugitive dust particles [29, 30]. These data strengthen the conclusion that the IL-6 secretion response of BEAS-2B cells to the pure oxides is small compared to other previously studied and environmentally relevant particle types.
Nano-sized SiO2 particles caused a statistically significant increase in IL-6 compared to both the untreated control and the cells treated with micron-sized SiO2 particles in six consecutive experiments with BEAS-2B cells indicating a reproducible pattern. For the other nano- and micron-sized particle pairs there was no conclusive evidence for the nanoparticles being consistently more potent than an equal mass concentration of the paired micron-sized particles.
The relative responses of BEAS-2B cells in the two types of cell culture media are characteristic of what we observed in a separate study comparing different in vitro lung cell models for particle toxicology [manuscript in preparation]. BEAS-2B cells in KGM media are highly responsive to vanadium and other soluble metals, as has been reported by others [31–34], but show relatively low response to LPS. In LHC-9 media the relative response to LPS and soluble metals is reversed.
The focus of this study was on IL-6 secretion by BEAS-2B cells, but we also measured IL-8 secretion and tested other cell types. Figure 4 shows typical IL-8 secretion data from a typical experiment with treatment at the high particle concentation. Again, any responses to the pure metal oxides are small and near control levels, and similar small responses were also seen at the low treatment concentration. Figure 5 shows typical IL-6 secretion in normal human bronchial epithelial cells (NHBE, Clonetics). The NHBE cells produce much higher control levels of IL-6 than the BEAS-2B cells, but the increased secretion in response to the pure oxide particles is small for both the 53 and 5.3 μg/cm2 particle treatmetn concentrations.
During initial experiments we observed apparent artifacts in the measured cytokine concentrations and hypothesized that surface adsorption on some particles reduced the ELISA measurements. Experiments were conducted in which a known amount of recombinant IL-6 was added to suspensions of particles in cell culture media and in media with supplemental protein. The data were consistent with non-specific binding of IL-6 to surfaces. Figure 6a and 6b show the effect of increasing exogenous protein supplementation using bovine serum albumin (BSA) or newborn calf serum on the measured IL-6 concentration in cell-free suspensions of kaolin, nano-sized SiO2, and TiO2. Without particles the measured IL-6 in cell culture media was close to the standard in serum-based assay diluent. The presence of 200 μg/mL of particles reduced the measured IL-6 concentration compared to the IL-6 standard in assay diluent, denoted by * in the graph. The measured IL-6 concentration increased with increasing amounts of supplemental protein. Addition of greater than 0.1% BSA and 1% FCS to the media resulted in a statistically significant increase in measured IL-6 compared to the same particle suspension without supplemental protein, denoted by # in the graph. Both the SiO2 and TiO2nanoparticles resulted in a statistically significant reduction in measured IL-6 compared to the standard for all mixtures including the highest tested protein supplementation: 3% BSA and 10% FCS. The highest level of protein supplementation eliminated the measurement artifact for 200 ug/mL of kaolin. The results presented were obtained with KGM media, but similar results were seen with LHC-9 media (data not shown).
Figure 6c shows the effect of adding logarithmically increasing concentrations of kaolin and nano-sized Fe2O3, SiO2, and TiO2 particles to cell culture media without supplemental protein. Particle concentrations of 3.1, 10, and 31 μg/mL did not cause a statistically significant decrease in measured IL-6. The p-values for 100 μg/mL of kaolin and nano-SiO2 were only slightly greater than 0.05, and the 316 μg/mL concentration of all particles resulted in a statistically significant decrease. The 100 μg/mL particle concentration corresponds to the 53 μg/cm2 particle concentration which was used as the high treatment level in the cell response experiments (400 μL suspension in a 0.75 cm2 well). Protein concentrations, measured by the Bradford assay and compared to a BSA standard, are 24 and 39 μg/mL for as-formulated KGM and LHC-9 media respectively. Media used for cell culture contains slightly higher protein due to cell secretions (2 – 4 μg/mL increase at 24 h). The use of 0.1% BSA in the cell culture media therefore corresponds to about a 50-fold increase in soluble protein available to block non-specific binding.
The wetted plastic area in the cell culture well is about 2.4 cm2. In contrast, at 100 μg/mL of particles and 400 μL of suspension per cell culture well the nitrogen adsorption surface area of the particles ranges from 19 cm2 for kaolin to 210 cm2 for nano-Al2O3, which is 1–2 orders of magnitude more than the wetted plastic surface area. Even if nitrogen adsorption area is a poor surrogate for the surface area available for aqueous protein adsorption, the difference in calculated area of the plastic and the particles supports the hypothesis that IL-6 adsorption on particle surfaces was the mechanism responsible for the measurement artifact.
Additional experiments were conducted with nano- and micron-sized SiO2 at higher concentration of BSA than used for the Figure 2 data. The data, Figure 7, show that the response of BEAS-2B cells to the SiO2 particles remains small, and this supports the conclusion that, with this in vitro model, pure oxide nanoparticles are not highly potent compared to either the soil-derived dusts or the positive controls. Figure 7 suggests that the measured rank order of response to the nano- and micron-sized particles may switch as the exogeneous protein is increased, but the difference between particle sizes did not reach statistical significance for the 3% BSA concentration. The control levels of IL-6 also showed a statistically significant increase with increased BSA: 3, 9, 15 pg/mL for zero, 0.3 and 3% BSA respectively. Also, 3% BSA appears to reduce the growth rate of the BEAS-2B cells relative to the as-formulated media.
We compared the relative potency of different commercial LPS preparations (Sigma) to verify that the low response to LPS was not due to the specific LPS type selected. Figure 8 shows the response of BEAS-2B cells in KGM (8a) and LHC-9 (8b) media to treatment with 100 and 1000 endotoxin units/mL (EU/mL) of commercial LPS from Escherichia coli 055:B5, Klebsiella pneumoniae, Pseudomonas aeruginosa serotype10. The E. coli and P. aeruginosa LPS had similar potency. The data also show that the response of BEAS-2B cells to all three tested types of LPS was higher when the cells were cultured in LHC-9 media compared to KGM.
The potency to induce IL-6 in BEAS-2B cells does not correlate with the extracellular generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS). Typical data for the generation of ROS by particles in cell-free culture media are shown in Figure 9. These data are measurements of the relative fluorescence 5 minutes after adding 300 μg/mL of particles to KGM media, and are typical of readings taken from 1 to 10 minutes after adding the probe. The nano-sized NiO produced the highest level of fluorescence from DCFH reagent oxidation. For CeO, NiO, SiO2 and TiO2 the nanoparticles produced statistically higher fluorescence than the micron-sized particles. Figure 9b compares the nanoparticles of NiO and SiO2 to the three soil derived dusts.
We used the in vitro responses of cultured human lung epithelial cells as a model system to study the potential inhalation health effects of several types of commercially available manufactured nanoparticles of metal and ceramic oxides. Similar in vitro airway epithelial cell models have been used to study many other types of environmentally relevant PM. Examples of studies with BEAS-2B cells include ambient particulate matter, residual oil fly ash,[31, 33, 36] wood smoke and Mt St. Helens ash,  and tire and pavement wear particles.  Examples of work with A549 cells includes TiO2 and Fe2O3, urban PM,  road and quarry dust [6, 40] and swine barn dust. In vitro models are ideal for studying molecular mechanisms of toxicity because of the ease of manipulation and because the simplified biological system is not confounded by regulatory processes acting in the whole animal. Studies of this type are frequently designed to study specific toxicological mechanisms by inducing a strong response that can be ameliorated by cotreatment with antagonists.
The small difference between equal mass doses of nano- and micron-sized particles of the same nominal substance and the general low level of response to the oxide particles were contrary to the initial study hypothesis. Further investigation into molecular mechanisms of oxide nanoparticle interaction with airway cells will require an alternative in vitro model because the responses of BEAS-2B cells to nanoparticles were small. Our observation of small size-dependent differences may be due to either the low potency of the pure oxide particles or the characteristics of the BEAS-2B cells.
The pure metal oxides may not be highly potent for inducing proinflammatory cytokine signaling responses in lung epithelial cell lines. If true, this is good news for the manufacturers and users of oxide nanoparticles. Most in vitro reports of high potency for nanoparticles have involved either carbon-rich particles [42, 43] or macrophage-like cell types such as RAW264.7,  J774A.1,  or THP-1 . However, it is possible that the immortalized BEAS-2B epithelial cells do not respond to particles in the same way as tissues in a whole animal. The widely assumed hypothesis that nanoparticles are more potent is based largely on the seminal animal exposure studies with carbon black  and TiO2. Caution is needed when comparing the rank order of potency of particles in vitro and in vivo, as was illustrated in a comparison of gasoline and diesel engine particles. 
We used crystalline silica (Min-U-Sil) as a prototype supermicron particle with known lung-damaging effects, but saw low cytotoxicity and IL-6 response. In seven experiments where control levels of IL-6 were well within the limit of detection the fold increase in response to a 50 μg/cm2 treatment with Min-U-Sil ranged from 1.8- to 7.3-fold. The literature reports on the response of cultured cells to specific particle types, such as silica, shows complex and somewhat inconsistent patterns. Our observed response to Min-U-Sil and TiO2 can be compared to the results of Steerenberg et al.,  who reported no increase over control for IL-6 in BEAS-2B cells treated with TiO2, comparable responses for diesel particles and α-quartz (17 ± 16 and 11 ± 15 fold), and higher response (59 ± 57 fold) response to fumed silica. Steerenberg's results suggest that different silica preparations have different potency, and that the IL-6 response of BEAS-2B cells is highly variable as indicated in Steerenberg's data where the standard deviation of IL-6 was comparable to the mean. A study by Xu et al. showed an inverted dose-response in A549 cells treated with Min-U-Sil with the 0.039 mg/mL treatment giving higher response than the 0.62 or 2.5 mg/mL treatments . Xu also reported standard deviations approaching 50% of the mean for IL-6 response. In another study, DQ12 quartz was more cytotoxic than silicasol particles (60 and 100 nm) and neither quartz or silicasol nanoparticles induced IL-6 in A549 cells.  Micron-sized TiO2 is sometimes considered an inert particle and used as a negative control in particle studies, [30, 49] but other studies have shown that nano-TiO2 can be proinflammatory in vivo [47, 51] and can be taken up by nonphagocytic mechanisms by macrophages in vitro .
The comparisons of nano- and micron-sized oxide particles with environmental dusts provide an important context to interpret the cytokine results. Taken in isolation, our data show patterns, for example nano-sized silica inducing a statistically significant response compared to the micron-sized silica. However, as shown in Figures 2c and 2d and Figure 3 the IL-6 secretion of BEAS-2B cells treated with all the pure oxide particle types is low compared to the response to both the positive controls and some samples of soil-derived dust, a ubiquitous pollutant that is often considered benign. Further, the response of BEAS-2B cells to soil-derived dust is comparable to, or smaller than, the response of these cells to soluble metal salts such as synthetic residual oil fly ash (ROFA) used in our work  and in many studies by the US EPA [31–34, 53, 54] and others. The relative potency of the metal oxide, environmental, and soluble metal-rich materials suggests the possibility that most of the variation shown in Figures 2a and 2b consists of artifacts occuring near the control level of IL-6 and not robust oxide particle-induced signaling responses relevant to tissue inflammation.
The low potency of the metal oxides is consistent with our previous work showing that IL-6 secretion by BEAS-2B cells is correlated to the low volatility organic components  and that heating soil-derived dust to 300–550°C removes the potent components from soil-derived dusts. We have previously considered the possibility that the potent factor in the soil-derived dusts is endotoxin. Evidence includes the poor correlation between the potency for inducing IL-6 and the endotoxin content , and the observation that the response to the soil-derived particles is much greater than the response to commercial endotoxin applied at much higher concentration than the measured endotoxin in the dust sample.  The rank order of IL-6 secretion and endotoxin content for the DD, JE and MNC samples correlate, but the correlation of IL-6 with endotoxin was weaker in a larger group of 28 samples giving an R2 = 0.43 . As seen in Table 2, the potency rank order of the three soil-derived dusts correlates with the both the endotoxin content and the organic carbon content, supporting the hypothesis that other organic compounds besides endotoxin may be the potent factor(s).
The extracellular generation of ROS by surface-catalyzed reactions [55–58] has been proposed as a mechanism by which particles may damage biomolecules  or activate cell-surface receptor proteins. [59, 60] In this study the potency for induction of IL-6 secretion did not correlate with extracellular ROS. The lack of correlation between ROS and cytokine response is similar to the results of Ovrevik et al. in a study of mineral particles and iron content.  A study with NHBE cells treated with coarse, fine, and ultrafine ambient particles found that the coarse PM was more potent for inducing cytokines but not intracellular ROS. 
Caution is needed in generalizing from these in vitro results to human exposures because of effects associated with the particular biological model used for the experiments. Because cells in vitro are isolated from the chemical and neural signaling that takes place in a whole organism there is no a priori reason to expect any one cell model to be the best surrogate for tissues in vivo. In a concurrent project we have found that different combinations of cell line, culture media, and passaging protocol details can change the cytokine secretion response to a given particle treatment [Manuscript in preparation]. We therefore reported the results of the same particle treatments used in several different cell models, and further compared the manufactured oxide particles to other particles previously tested using the same cell line and protocol.
High surface area materials can adsorb chemicals from cell culture media and therefore confound data from in vitro toxicology experiments. Adsorbtion of cytokines has been shown by both the work of Seagrave et al.  with IL-8 in the presence of carbon black, and our experiments with IL-6 in the presence of oxide particles. Carbon particles have also been reported to adsorb indicators, such as neutral red and MTT, from the media introducing artifacts into viability assays.  Particle surfaces can have indirect effects on cells in vitro by adsorbing trace nutrients or growth factors from the finite volume of culture media and making these vital factors less available to the cells. 
A key confounding issue is the extent that the cytokine adsorbtion artifact presented in Figures 6 and 7 is responsible for the low potency of the oxide particles when compared to soils and the small differences between the nano-sized and micron-sized particles. Figure 7 suggests that the rank order may be influenced by the adsorbtion artifact, but this is a qualitative trend that did not reach statistical significance. The experiments quantifying the effect of supplemental protein on cell-free measurements of IL-6 indicated that the particle concentration used for the cell treatments was borderline for causing a statistically significant reduction in measured IL-6. Combined, this evidence suggests that the low responses to metal oxide particle treatments reported in this study are a real lack of cell activation and not the result of a false negative artifact. Given the general low level of in vitro BEAS-2B cell response to the oxide particles compared to the environmental particles, it may be more productive to do further study of particle size differences in another cell model and measuring other endpoints. However, the possibility that nanoparticles, and other high-surface-area particles can cause non-biological artifacts should be considered in the design of future experiments.
This study, using lung epithelial cells in vitro, indicates that manufactured particles of Al, Ce, Fe, Ni, Si, and Ti oxides occasionally induced statistically significant increases in the secretion of the proinflammatory cytokines IL-6 and IL-8, but these responses were not robust and were small compared to certain soil-derived environmental dusts and positive controls. We tested the hypothesis that nano-sized metal oxide particles are more potent than micron-sized particles of the same nominal substance, but results were inconclusive due to the low responses. The changes in cytokine secretion by the oxide particle-treated cells are detectable, but may not be biologically important because the particle-induced responses are comparable to passage-to-passage variation in control levels and are small compared to the effects of other potential agonists such as TNF-α, a cytokine produced by macrophages in response to particles in vivo. Animal studies with carbon particles continue to report inflammatory responses that correlate with surface area , so the lack of a consistent size-dependent response in this study may reflect either a difference between inorganic oxide versus carbon/organic particles or a difference between cell culture and whole animal responses. High concentrations of suspended particles, especially nano-sized particles, can interfere with ELISA measurements of cytokine secretion, and this should be considered in both interpretation of the published literature and in the design of future experimentals.
This study adds to the growing literature on the biological effects of nanomaterials. While inhalation exposure to any mineral dust should be minimized, this in vitro study suggests that manufactured metal oxide nanoparticles are not exceptionally potent for causing proinflammatory signaling in airway epithelial cells when compared to more conventional ambient and occupational dusts.
The nano-sized and micron-sized particles and the positive controls were purchased from commercial suppliers indicated in Table 1. The three soil-derived dusts DD, JE, and MNC were derived from field samples collected on an unpaved desert road in Utah, on an urban street in Ciadud Juàrez, Mexico, and from native soil at a remote desert site in Utah respectively. The DD, JE, and MNC particles are identical to samples 18, 16, 28 respectively in  which deals with the correlation between chemical composition of soil-derived dusts and IL-6 induction in BEAS-2B cells. The samples DD and MNC also correspond to UTDG and UTMC in  which contains detailed composition data and describes the procedures used for chemical analysis. The field samples were resuspended in the laboratory, and the particles were aerodynamically separated to provide a PM2.5-enriched material for the cell treatments as previously described [30, 67].
Particle surface area per mass was measured by nitrogen adsorption (BET single point method) using a Quantachrome Monosorb analyzer. Surface determinations were run in duplicate for both the adsorption and desorption periods. Surface mean diameter was calculated assuming spherical particles and the mineral density from handbooks.
Four different cell culture models were used: the immortalized cell line BEAS-2B in LHC-9 media, BEAS-2B cells in KGM media, A549 cells in DMEM/F12, and normal human bronchial epithelial cells (NHBE) in BEGM media. Table 3 summarizes the details of the protocols used for the different cell culture models. The generic cell culture protocol consisted of growing the cells in an incubator at 37°C/6% CO2 in 75 or 150 cm2 flasks, replacing media every 2–3 days, and passaging before confluence by dislodging with trypsin, washing, and seeding new flasks or treatment wells. The use of LHC-9 media for BEAS-2B cells was based on the original work of Lechner et al. , particle studies by other laboratories, for example , and our prior studies. [29, 30] The protocol for BEAS-2B cells in KGM was based on the methods originally developed by the US EPA and since used in multiple studies [31, 36, 70, 71]. The protocol for the NHBE cells was based on the supplier's recommendation. Particle experiments consisted of seeding 48-well plates (Costar, Fisher Scientific) with cells, allowing a recovery period for the cells to attach and proliferate, replacing the culture media with fresh media containing the treatments, and harvesting the media for cytokine analysis 24 hr after treatment. Culture media were used both as formulated and with 0.1% added bovine serum albumin.
Particles were weighed, mixed with cell culture media, and resuspended by sonication and vortexing immediately before adding to the cell wells. The treatment experimental design consisted of multiple treatments applied to cells from a single passage to minimize confounding of comparisons by passage-to-passage variation of the cultured cells. Each multiwell cell culture plate included positive and negative controls. Results were replicated using additional independent passages of cells. Particle treatment concentrations were 0.53, 5.3 and 53 μg/cm2 which correspond to 1, 10 and 100 μg/mL respectively for the cell culture plates and media volumes used.
Viable cell count was measured using the Cell Counting Kit -8 assay from Dojindo Laboratories. This assay assumes that the relative number of cells is linear with the metabolic activity indicated by mitocondrial reduction of WST-8 (2-(2-methoxy-4-nitrophenyl)-3-(4-nitrophenyl)-5-(2,4-disulfophenyl)-2H-tetrazolium, monosodium salt) to produce a water-soluble product. Data are quantified by absorption at 450 nm, corrected by absorption at 650 nm, using a Molecular Devices plate reader.
Cytokine protein secretion
The cytokines IL-6 and IL-8 were measured using an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Antibodies, cytokine standard, and avidin horseradish peroxidase (AVHRP) for IL-6 were obtained from eBioscience; the IL-8 assay used a Human CXCL8/IL-8 DuoSet kit (DY208) from R&D Systems. Nunc MaxiSorp immuno plates (Fisher Scientific) were coated overnight with antibody; room-temperature incubations on a plate rocker were carried out with sample and standards, biotin-conjugated antibody, and AVHRP with thorough washing with 0.05% Tween-20 in PBS pH 7.0 between steps. After a 1-hour incubation with ABTS substrate, the plates were read at 405 nm using a Molecular Devices plate reader with SoftMax Pro software, and cytokine concentrations were calculated against a standard curve prepared in duplicate.
Cell-free artifacts of high-surface PM
The experiments to quantify particle artifacts in the cytokine analysis used the addition of known amounts of recombinant human IL-6 from R&D Systems to various aqueous phases including water, phosphate buffered saline, LHC-9 or KGM cell culture media, cell culture media supplemented with serum or BSA, and media conditioned by growing cells for 24-h. Mixtures of IL-6 in the aqueous phase were incubated alone or with particles, centrifuged to separate the particles, decanted, and stored frozen until analyzed by ELISA. Cytokine quantification was by both direct comparison of measured concentrations in particle-free versus particle-treated samples and by a standard curve using recombinant IL-6 in serum-based assay diluent and prepared in duplicate at the time of analysis. Most cell-free experiments used concentrations similar to typical cell culture experiments, for example, 100 μg/mL particles, 200 pg/mL IL-6. However, the hypothesis-testing experimental conditions were varied over a wide range using logarithmically spaced nominal values: particles from zero to 400 μg/mL, IL-6 from zero to 10,000 pg/mL, incubation time from 5 minutes to overnight.
Endotoxin was measured using the chromogenic Limulus Amebocyte Lysate (LAL) assay kit QCL-1000 (Cambrex Biosciences).
The generation of reactive oxygen species in cell-free media was determined using the dichlorodihydrofluorescein diacetate (DCFH-DA) reagent (Molecular Probes #D-399). The method was based on studies of extracellular ROS generation by silica . For cell-free experiments the acetate was cleaved to form the non-fluorescent precursor by treatment with 0.1 M NaOH followed by neutralization and dilution to working concentration. Dichlorodihydrofluorescein (DCFH) is converted to the fluorescent product dichlorofluorescein by oxidation. Particles were added to 10 μM DCFH at 10–1000 μg/mL final concentration, incubated, and read at fixed intervals starting immediately after DCFH addition. Data in Figure 9 were from the third reading, nominally starting at 5 minutes. Fluorescence was read on a Perkin Elmer Victor 3 V Multilabel counter using 485 nm excitation and 535 nm emission. Freshly diluted hydrogen peroxide was used as a positive control.
Data were analyzed with JMP software (SAS Institute). Paired comparisons were made using Student's t-test, comparison of multiple treatments to a common control used one-way ANOVA with Dunnett's test, and p < 0.05 was considered significant.
HEI: Understanding the Health Effects of Components of the Particulate Matter Mix: Progress and Next Steps. Cambridge, MA , Health Effects Institute; 2002.
Kelley J: Cytokines of the lung. In Lung Biology in Health and Disease. Volume 61. New York , Marcel Dekker; 1993.
Nelson S, Martin TR: Cytokines in pulmonary disease: infection and inflammation. In Lung Biology in health and disease. Volume 141. New York , Marcel Dekker; 2000.
Thèze J: The Cytokine Network and Immune Functions. New York , Oxford University Press; 1999.
Mills PR, Davies RJ, Devalia JL: Airway epithelial cells, cytokines, and pollutants. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1999, 160: S38-S43.
Hetland RB, Refsnes M, Myran T, Johansen BV, Uthus N, Schwartz PE: Mineral and/or metal content as critical determinants of particle-induced release of IL-6 and IL-8 from A549 cells. J Toxicol Environ Health A 2000,60(1):47–65. 10.1080/009841000156583
Veronesi B, Wei G, Zeng JQ, Oortgiesen M: Electrostatic charge activates inflammatory vanilloid (VR1) receptors. NeuroToxicology 2003, 24: 463–473. 10.1016/S0161-813X(03)00022-6
Becker S, Soukup JM, Sioutas C, Cassee FR: Response of human alveolar macrophages to ultrafine, fine, and coarse urban air pollution particles. Exp Lung Res 2003,29(1):29–44. 10.1080/01902140303762
Smith KR, Veranth JM, Hu AA, Lighty JAS, Aust AE: Interleukin-8 levels in human lung epithelial cells are increased in response to coal fly ash and vary with bioavailability of iron, as a function of particle size and source of coal. Chem Res Toxicol 2000, 13: 118–125. 10.1021/tx9901736
Stringer B, Imrich A, Kobzik L: Lung epithelial cell (A549) interaction with unopsonized environmental particulates: quantitation of particle-specific binding and IL-8 production. Exp Lung Res 1996,22(5):495–508.
Koyama S, Sato E, Nomura H, Kubo K, Miura M, Yamashita T, Nagai S, Izumi T: The potential of various lipopolysaccharides to release IL-8 and G-CSF. Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol 2000, 278: L658-L666.
Driscoll KE: TNF alpha and MIP-2: role in particle-induced inflammation and regulation by oxidative stress. Toxicol Lett 2000, 112–113: 177–183. 10.1016/S0378-4274(99)00282-9
Smirnov IM, Bailey K, Flowers CH, Garrigues NW, Wesselius LJ: Effects of TNF-alpha and IL-1beta on iron metabolism by A549 cells and influence on cytotoxicity. Am J Physiol 1999,277(2 Pt 1):L257–263.
Brown DM, Donaldson K, Borm PJ, Schins PR, Denhart M, Gilmour P, Jimenez LA, Stone V: Calcium and ROS-mediated activation of transcription factors and TNFa cytokine gene expression in macrophages exposed to ultrafine particles. Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol 2003, 286: L344-L353. 10.1152/ajplung.00139.2003
Aust AE, Ball JC, Hu A, Lighty JAS, Smith KR, Straccia AM, Veranth JM, Young WC: Particle characteristics responsible for effects on human lung epithelial cells. Res Rep Health Eff Inst 2002, 110: 1–65.
Devlin RB, Ghio AJ, Costa DL: Responses of Inflammatory Cells. In Particle-Lung Interactions. Edited by: Gehr P, Heyder J. New York , Marcel Dekker; 2000:437–472.
Rice TM, Clarke RW, Godleski JJ, Al-Mutairi E, Jiang NF, Hauser R, Paulauskis JD: Differential ability of transition metals to induce pulmonary inflammation. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 2001, 177: 46–53. 10.1006/taap.2001.9287
Zelikoff JT, Schermerhorn KR, Fang K, Cohen MD, Schlesinger RB: A role for associated transition metals in the immunotoxicity of inhaled ambient particulate matter. Environ Health Perspect 2002, 110 Suppl 5: 871–875.
Wilson MR, Lightbody JH, Donaldson K, Sales J, Stone V: Interactions between ultrafine particles and transition metals in vivo and in vitro. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 2002,184(3):172–179. 10.1006/taap.2002.9501
Prahalad AK, Inmom J, Dailey LA, Madden MC, Ghio AJ, Gallagher JE: Air pollution particles mediated oxidative DNA base damage in a cell free system and in human airway epithelial cells in relation to particulate metal content and bioreactivity. Chem Res Toxicol 2001,14(7):879–887. 10.1021/tx010022e
Baulig A, Garlatti M, Bonvallot V, Marchand A, Barouki R, Marano F, Baeza-Squiban A: Involvement of reactive oxygen species in the metabolic pathways triggered by diesel exhaust particles in human airway epithelial cells. Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol 2003, 285: L671-L679.
McNeilly JD, Heal MR, Beverland IJ, Howe A, Gibson MD, Hibbs LR, MacNee W, Donaldson K: Soluble transition metals cause the pro-inflammatory effects of welding fumes in vitro. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 2004, 196: 95–107. 10.1016/j.taap.2003.11.021
Imrich A, Kobzik L: Flow cytometric analysis of macrophage oxidative metabolism using DCFH. In Flow Cytometry Protocols. Volume 91 Methods in Molecular Biology. Edited by: Jaroszeski MJ, Heller R. Totowa NJ , Humana Press; 1998:97–108.
Halliwell B, Gutteridge JMC: Free Radicals in Biology and Medicine (Third Ed.). 3rd edition. Oxford , Oxford University Press; 1999.
Li XY, Brown D, Smith S, MacNee W, Donaldson K: Short-term inflammatory responses following intratracheal instillation of fine and ultrafine carbon black in rats. Inhal Toxicol 1999,11(8):709–31. 10.1080/089583799196826
Churg A, Gilks B, Dai J: Induction of fibrogenic mediators by fine and ultrafine titanium dioxide in rat tracheal explants. Am J Physiol 1999, 277: L975-L982.
Donaldson K, Brown D, Coulter A, Duffin R, MacNee W, Renwick L, Tran L, Stone V: The pulmonary toxicology of ultrafine particles. J Aerosol Med 2002,15(2):213–220. 10.1089/089426802320282338
Oberdörster G: Pulmonary effects of inhaled ultrafine particles. Int Arch Occup Environ Health 2001, 74: 1–8. 10.1007/s004200000185
Veranth JM, Reilly CA, Veranth MM, Moss TA, Langelier CR, Lanza DL, Yost GS: Inflammatory cytokines and cell death in BEAS-2B lung cells treated with soil dust, lipopolysaccharide, and surface-modified particles. Toxicol Sci 2004, 82: 88–96. 10.1093/toxsci/kfh248
Veranth JM, Moss TA, Chow JC, Labban R, Nichols WK, Walton JC, Watson JG, Yost GS: Correlation of in vitro cytokine responses with the chemical composition of soil-derived particulate matter. Environ Health Perspect 2006,114(3):341–9.
Oortgiesen M, Veronesi B, Eichenbaum G, Kiser PF, Simon SA: Residual oil fly ash and charged polymers activate epithelial cells and nociceptive sensory neurons. Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol 2000,278(4):L683–95.
Samet JM, Stonehuerner J, Reed W, Devlin RB, Dailey LA, Kennedy TP, Bromberg PA, Ghio AJ: Disruption of protein tyrosine phosphate homeostasis in bronchial epithelial cells exposed to oil fly ash. Am J Physiol 1997, 272: L426-L432.
Quay JL, Reed W, Samet J, Devlin RB: Air pollution particles induce IL-6 gene expression in human airway epithelial cells via NF-kappaB activation. Am J Respir Cell Mol Biol 1998,19(1):98–106.
Veronesi B, Oortgiesen M, Carter JD, Devlin RB: Particulate matter initiates inflammatory cytokine release by activation of capsaicin and acid receptors in a human bronchial epithelial cell line. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 1999, 154: 106–115. 10.1006/taap.1998.8567
Kennedy T, Ghio AJ, Reed W, Samet J, Zagorski J, Quay J, Carter J, Dailey L, Hoidal JR, Devlin RB: Copper-dependent inflammation and nuclear factor -kappaB activation by particulate air pollution. Am J Respir Cell Mol Biol 1998,19(3):366–78.
Ghio AJ, Carter JD, Dailey LA, Devlin RB, Samet JM: Respiratory epithelial cells demonstrate lactoferrin receptors that increase after metal exposure. Am J Physiol 1999,276(6 Pt 1):L933–40.
Veronesi B, de Haar C, Roy J, Oortgiesen M: Particulate matter inflammation and receptor sensitivity are target cell specific. Inhal Toxicol 2002, 14: 159–183. 10.1080/089583701753403971
Lindbom J, Gustafsson M, Blomqvist G, Dahl A, Gudmundsson A, Swietlicki E, Ljungman AG: Exposure to wear particles generated from studded tires and pavement induces inflammatory cytokine release from human macrophages. Chem Res Toxicol 2006,19(4):521–530. 10.1021/tx0503101
Smith KR, Aust AE: Mobilization of iron from urban particulates leads to generation of reactive oxygen species in vitro and induction of ferritin synthesis in human lung epithelial cells. Chem Res Toxicol 1997,10(7):828–834. 10.1021/tx960164m
Øvrevik J, Myran T, Refsnes M, Lag M, Becher R, Hetland RB, Schwarze PE: Mineral particles of varying composition induce differential chemokine release from epithelial lung cells: importance of physico-chemical characteristics. Ann Occup Hyg 2005,49(3):219–31. 10.1093/annhyg/meh087
Lidén J, Ek A, Palmberg L, Okret S, Larrson K: Organic dust activates NF-kB in lung epithelial cells. Respiratory Medicine 2003, 97: 882–892. 10.1016/S0954-6111(03)00111-2
Barlow PG, Coulter-Baker A, Donaldson K, MacCallum J, Stone V: Carbon black nanoparticles induce type II epithelial cells to release chemotaxins for alveolar macrophages. Part Fibre Toxicol 2005, 2: 11. 10.1186/1743-8977-2-11
Möller W, Brown DM, Kreyling WG, Stone V: Ultrafine particles cause cytoskeletal dysfunctions in macrophages: role of intracellular calcium. Part Fibre Toxicol 2005, 2: 7. 10.1186/1743-8977-2-7
Xia T, Kovochich M, Brant J, Hotze M, Sempf J, Oberley T, Sioutas C, Yeh JI, Wiesner MR, Nel AE: Comparison of the abilities of ambient and manufactured nanoparticles to induce cellular toxicity according to an oxidative stress paradigm. Nano Letters 2006,6(8):1794–1804. 10.1021/nl061025k
Wottrich R, Diabate S, Krug HF: Biological effects of ultrafine model particles in human macrophages and epithelial cells in mono- and co-culture. Int J Hyg Environ Health 2004,207(4):353–361. 10.1078/1438-4639-00300
Donaldson K: Local inflammatory and systemic effects following short-term inhalation exposure to fine and ultrafine carbon black in rats . In The Health Effects of Fine Particles: Key Questions and the 2003 Review, Brussels Belgium. Health Effects Institute, 1999, Communications No. 8, p. II-171;
Oberdörster G, Ferin J, Gelein R, Soderholm SC, Finkelstein J: Role of the Aveolar Macrophage in Lung Injury; Studies with Ultrafine Particles. Environ Health Perspect 1992, 97: 193–199. 10.2307/3431353
Seagrave J, Mauderly JL, Seilkop SK: In vitro relative toxicity screening of combined particulate and semivolatile organic fractions of gasoline and diesel engine emissions. J Toxicol Environ Health A 2003,66(12):1113–1132.
Steerenberg PA, Zonnenberg JA, Dormans JA, Joon PN, Wouters IM, van Bree L, Scheepers PT, Van Loveren H: Diesel exhaust particles induced release of interleukin 6 and 8 by (primed) human bronchial epithelial cells (BEAS 2B) in vitro. Exp Lung Res 1998,24(1):85–100.
Xu H, Dinsdale D, Nemery B, Hoet PHM: Role of residual additives in the cytotoxicity and cytokine release caused by polyvinyl chloride particles in pulmonary cell cultures. Toxicol Sci 2003, 72: 92–102. 10.1093/toxsci/kfg003
Chen HW, Su SF, Chien CT, Lin WH, Yu SL, Chou CC, Yang PC: Titanium dioxide nanoparticles induce emphysema-like lung injury in mice. FASEB J 2006,20(13):2393–5. 10.1096/fj.06-6485fje
Geiser M, Rothen-Rutishauser B, Kapp N, Schurch S, Kreyling WG, Schultz H, Im Hof V, Hyder J, Gehr P: Ultrafine particles can cross cellular membranes by nonphagocytic mechanisms in lungs and cultured cell. Environ Health Perspect 2005,113(11):1555–1560.
Carter JD, Ghio AJ, Samet JM, Devlin RB: Cytokine production by human airway epithelial cells after exposure to an air pollution particle is metal-dependent. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 1997,146(2):180–188. 10.1006/taap.1997.8254
Ghio AJ: Biologic effects of oil fly ash. Environ Health Perspect 2002,110(1):89–94.
Kadiiska MB, Mason RP, Dreher KL, Costa DL, Ghio AJ: In vivo evidence of free radical formation in the rat lung after exposure to an emission source air pollution particle. Chem Res Toxicol 1997,10(10):1104–1108. 10.1021/tx970049r
Ball BR, Smith KR, Veranth JM, Aust AE: Bioavailability of iron from coal fly ash: mechanisms of mobilization and of biological effects. Inhal Toxicol 2000, 12 Suppl 4: 209–225. 10.1080/089583700750019576
Deshpande A, Narayanan PK, Lehnert BE: Silica-induced generation of extracellular factor(s) increases reactive oxygen species in human bronchial epithelial cells. Toxicol Sci 2002,67(2):275–283. 10.1093/toxsci/67.2.275
Hetland RB, Myhre O, Lag M, Hongve D, Schwarze PE, Refsnes M: Importance of soluble metals and reactive oxygen species for cytokine release induced by mineral particles. Toxicology 2001,165((2–3)):133–144. 10.1016/S0300-483X(01)00418-8
Swain WA, O'Bryne KJ, Faux SP: Activation of p38 MAP kinase is rat mesothelial cells is mediated by oxidative stress. Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol 2004, 286: L859-L865. 10.1152/ajplung.00162.2003
Fubini B, Hubbard A: Reactive oxygen species (ROS) and reactive nitrogen species (RNS) generation by silica in inflammation and fibrosis. Free Radic Biol Med 2003,34(12):1507–1516. 10.1016/S0891-5849(03)00149-7
Ovrevik J, Hetland RB, Schins RP, Myran T, Schwarze PE: Iron release and ROS generation from mineral particles are not related to cytokine release or apoptosis in exposed A549 cells. Toxicol Lett 2006,165(1):31–38. 10.1016/j.toxlet.2006.01.012
Becker S, Dailey LA, Soukup JM, Grambow SC, Devlin RB, Huang YC: Seasonal variations in air pollution particle-induced inflammatory mediator release and oxidative stress. Environ Health Perspect 2005,113(8):1032–1038.
Seagrave JC, Knall C, McDonald JD, Mauderly JL: Diesel particulate material binds and concentrates a proinflammatory cytokine that causes neutrophil migration. Inhal Toxicol 2004, 16 (suppl. 1): 93–98. 10.1080/08958370490443178
Monteiro-Riviere NA, Inman AO: Challenges for assessing carbon nanomaterial toxicity to the skin. Carbon 2006, 44: 1070–1078. 10.1016/j.carbon.2005.11.004
Stoeger T, Reinhard C, Takenaka S, Schroppel A, Karg E, Ritter B, Heyder J, Schultz H: Instillation of six different ultrafine carbon particles indicates a surface area threshold dose for acute lung inflammation in mice. Environ Health Perspect 2006,114(3):328–333.
Labban R, Veranth JM, Chow JC, Englebrecht J, Watson J: Size and geographical variation in PM1, PM2.5, and PM10 source profiles from soils in the western United States. Water Air Soil Pollut 2004, 157: 13–21. 10.1023/B:WATE.0000038855.96607.c6
Veranth JM, Smith KR, Aust AE, Dansie SL, Griffith JB, Hu AA, Huggins ML, Lighty JAS: Coal fly ash and mineral dust for toxicology and particle characterization studies: Equipment and methods for PM2.5- and PM1-enriched samples. Aerosol Sci Technol 2000,32(2):127–141. 10.1080/027868200303830
Lechner JF, LaVeck MA: A serum-free method for culturing normal human bronchial epithelial cells at clonal density. J Tissue Culture Meth 1985, 9: 43–48. 10.1007/BF01797773
Huang SL, Hsu MK, Chan CC: Effects of submicrometer particle compositions on cytokine production and lipid peroxidation of human bronchial epithelial cells. Environ Health Perspect 2003,111(4):478–482.
Frampton MW, Ghio AJ, Samet JM, Carson JL, Carter JD, Devlin RB: Effects of aqueous extracts of PM(10) filters from the Utah Valley on human airway epithelial cells. Am J Physiol 1999, 277: L960-L967.
Veronesi B, de Haar C, Lee L, Oortgiesen M: The surface charge of visible particulate matter predicts biological activation in human bronchial epithelial cells. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 2002, 178: 144–154. 10.1006/taap.2001.9341
Training on the EPA cell culture protocol and a sample of BEAS-2B cells were generously provided by Robert Devlin and Lisa Dailey at US EPA. Technical help for this study was provided by N. Shane Cutler, Philip Moos, and Diane Lanza. Shared equipment was provided by Steve Kern, Kris Knutson, Philip Moos, and the U of U Health Sciences Center core facilities. Financial support for this work was provided by NIEHS K25 ES0011281, US EPA STAR RD 8317230, and SCERP A-04-04. This manuscript has not been submitted for agency review and opinions expressed are the responsibility of the authors.
The author(s) declare that they have no competing interests.
The study design, statistical analysis, and preparation of the manuscript were by JMV, cell culture experiments and ELISA assays were conducted by MK, EGK, and MMV, and data base assembly was by EGK. The diagnosis of the particle artifacts was by MMV. GSY provided advice, infrastructure, and assistance in preparation of the manuscript.
John M Veranth, Erin G Kaser, Martha M Veranth contributed equally to this work.
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
About this article
Cite this article
Veranth, J.M., Kaser, E.G., Veranth, M.M. et al. Cytokine responses of human lung cells (BEAS-2B) treated with micron-sized and nanoparticles of metal oxides compared to soil dusts. Part Fibre Toxicol 4, 2 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1186/1743-8977-4-2
- Normal Human Bronchial Epithelial
- Normal Human Bronchial Epithelial Cell
- Metal Oxide Particle
- Fugitive Dust
- Extracellular Reactive Oxygen Species