Role of chemical composition and redox modification of poorly soluble nanomaterials on their ability to enhance allergic airway sensitisation in mice
Particle and Fibre Toxicology volume 16, Article number: 39 (2019)
Engineered nanoparticles (NPs) have been shown to enhance allergic airways disease in mice. However, the influence of the different physicochemical properties of these particles on their adjuvant properties is largely unknown. Here we investigate the effects of chemical composition and redox activity of poorly soluble NPs on their adjuvant potency in a mouse model of airway hypersensitivity.
NPs of roughly similar sizes with different chemical composition and redox activity, including CeO2, Zr-doped CeO2, Co3O4, Fe-doped Co3O4(using Fe2O3 or Fe3O4) and TiO2 NPs, all showed adjuvant activity. OVA induced immune responses following intranasal exposure of BALB/c mice to 0.02% OVA in combination with 200 μg NPs during sensitization (on day 1, 3, 6 and 8) and 0.5% OVA only during challenge (day 22, 23 and 24) were more pronounced compared to the same OVA treatment regime without NPs. Changes in OVA-specific IgE and IgG1 plasma levels, differential cell count and cytokines in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF), and histopathological detection of mucosa cell metaplasia and eosinophil density in the conducting airways were observed. Adjuvant activity of the CeO2 NPs was primarily mediated via the Th2 response, while that of the Co3O4 NPs was characterised by no or less marked increases in IgE plasma levels, BALF IL-4 and IL-5 concentrations and percentages of eosinophils in BALF and more pronounced increases in BALF IL-6 concentrations and percentages of lymphocytes in BALF. Co-exposure to Co3O4 NPs with OVA and subsequent OVA challenge also induced perivascular and peribronchiolar lymphoid cell accumulation and formation of ectopic lymphoid tissue in lungs. Responses to OVA combined with various NPs were not affected by the amount of doping or redox activity of the NPs.
The findings indicate that chemical composition of NPs influences both the relative potency of NPs to exacerbate allergic airway sensitization and the type of immune response. However, no relation between the acellular redox activity and the observed adjuvant activity of the different NPs was found. Further research is needed to pinpoint the precise physiological properties of NPs and biological mechanisms determining adjuvant activity in order to facilitate a safe-by-design approach to NP development.
Engineered nanoparticles (NPs) are under increasing development for a wide-range of applications, however, their potential for toxicity still remains poorly understood. Identifying which physicochemical properties of NPs affect the potential toxicological effects will therefore facilitate predictive risk assessment, grouping and safe-by-design of NPs [1,2,3,4].
The relative large surface-to-volume ratio and surface reactivity of NPs are, for example, known to increase reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation [5, 6]. As a consequence, inhalation of NPs may lead to greater levels of cellular oxidative stress and, subsequently inflammation in the respiratory system, than their larger counterparts. In addition, existing inflammation (e.g. from asthma) can also be exacerbated by NP exposure [7, 8]. Nano-sized silica and titanium dioxide particles have been shown to enhance allergic airways sensitisation in mice [9, 10], however, there is limited understanding of the different physicochemical properties of NPs which influence their adjuvant properties. Previous studies on the influence of NPs on allergic airway sensitisation initially focussed on the role of the dendritic cell and T-cell interaction. Increases in the proliferation, maturation and/or differentiation of dendritic cells and T-cells have been observed after in vitro exposure to NPs and after in vivo exposure to NPs during the sensitisation phase . Molecular interactions that drive these cellular responses have been suggested to involve increases in reactive oxygen species (ROS) caused by NPs with an oxidative surface chemistry, inflammasome activation, cellular injury and the induction of dendritic cell simulating cytokines or chemokines by epithelial cells (either direct or via oxidative stress) .
Nano-sized metal oxides are known to facilitate the formation of ROS by depleting electrons from cellular redox species (cellular components able to release electrons) or by serving as catalysts in ROS production through Fenton reactions or Haber-Weiss cycle reactions . Additionally, NPs can stimulate free radical generation from cellular enzymes. Furthermore, biological fluids (e.g. epithelial lining fluid) and cells also contain antioxidants and numerous compensatory mechanisms, thus the relationship between ROS induction and toxicity is complex.
While there are clear associations between ROS generation and the toxicity of nanomaterials [11,12,13], the specific role of the redox activity of nanomaterials in the generation of ROS is difficult to investigate, since changing the redox activity of nanomaterials usually also changes other properties (such as the chemical composition or size). In a recent study, we applied chemical doping (intentional substitution of one element by another while maintaining the lattice structure and arrangement) of cerium dioxide to specifically investigate the influence of NP redox activity on ROS formation, and associated induction of oxidative stress responses in mice in vivo . Different quantities of zirconium (Zr) were incorporated into the crystalline structure of the cerium dioxide nanoparticles (CeO2 NPs) to increase the antioxidant potential. However, Zr-doping of CeO2 NPs had limited effect on the inflammatory responses after inhalation in otherwise healthy mice.
Metal oxides with a conduction band energy (Ec) level that overlaps with the cellular redox potential (− 4.12 to − 4.84 eV) have been shown to have the ability to induce oxygen radicals, oxidative stress, and acute pulmonary inflammation . Therefore, Co3O4, a metal oxide that (unlike CeO2) has an Ec level overlapping with the cellular redox potential was doped using Fe2O3 or Fe3O4 (Fe oxides themselves do not overlap with the cellular redox potential). Here we present an airway exposure study in a mouse model for airway allergy using the following poorly soluble NPs differing in redox potential but with similar sizes: a) Co3O4 NPs doped with different amounts of Fe, b) CeO2 NPs doped with different amounts of Zr, c) CeO2 NM212 NPs (for comparison to other in vivo studies) and d) TiO2 NPs (as a positive control ). We hypothesise that Co3O4 NPs will have a greater ability to enhance allergic airway sensitisation compared to (Zr-doped) CeO2 NPs, but that these effects of Co3O4 NPs can be reduced by Fe-doping. The outcome of this work will facilitate the assessment of the potential hazard of NPs to enhance allergic airway sensitisation and inform efforts to group NPs or to apply a safe-by-design approach in their development.
Studies were designed to test the enhancement of allergic sensitization by airway co-exposure (intranasal instillation) of an experimental allergen (OVA) with a range of NPs that differ in chemical composition (Fig. 1). Animals were divided into 10 test groups and 3 control groups, each with 6 mice except OVA-control (n = 8) (see Table 1). On days 1, 3, 6 and 8 the mice were sensitized with 0.02% OVA in combination with 200 μg TiO2 NPs (positive controls), 0.02% OVA in combination with 200 µg of one of the other NPs (test groups), 0.02% OVA in PBS (OVA control) or PBS alone (PBS control). On days 22 and 23 all mice were challenged with 30 μl of 0.5% OVA in PBS. The animals were sacrificed 24 h after the last intranasal challenge (day 24).
A dose of 200 μg of NPs was chosen based on our results in previous studies (with dose-ranges between 100 and 400 μg) using silica  and titanium dioxide . The mouse model was developed with low concentrations of OVA during sensitization (0.02%) that produce minimal allergic responses with challenge, but can be dramatically enhanced with co-sensitization with an adjuvant such as particulate matter .
No experimental groups were included to measure the effects of exposure to NPs without OVA during the sensitisation phase, since previous studies showed that the allergic sensitisation response can only be enhanced via co-exposure of the allergen and SiO2 or TiO2 NPs, and not by exposure to SiO2 and TiO2 NP NPs alone [9, 10]. Although other studies have shown that separate administration of the allergen and NPs may also lead to adjuvant effects , in this study we have chosen to administer OVA and NPs in one suspension, in alignment with our previous studies.
Nanomaterial production and characterization
TiO2 NPs (NO-0058-HP) were obtained from Ionic Liquids Technologies GmbH, Germany. These uncoated anatase TiO2 NPs were the same NPs as used on our previous in vivo study . The OECD representative manufactured nanomaterial CeO2 (NM212) was obtained from Umicore, Belgium. The other CeO2 NPs, Zr-doped CeO2 NPs, Co3O4 NPs and Fe-doped Co3O4 NPs were produced using supercritical water hydrothermal synthesis [17, 18]. Briefly, H2O was pumped through a pre-heating coil (~ 400 °C), brought into contact with a concurrently flowing solution of metal salts at room temperature (RT), while maintaining the flow rates, temperature and the pressure constant at 240 bar. The mixture was cooled immediately after the mixing point and passed through a back pressure regulator to decrease the pressure back down to ambient conditions. Solids in the aqueous suspensions were washed by centrifuging and re-dispersing in clean MilliQ water 3 times. The particles were characterised in suspension or, where solid particles were required, the suspensions were oven dried (~ 100 °C). For the synthesis of the Fe-doped Co3O4 NPs, different ratios of cobalt and iron salts were used as precursors. Two different iron salts (iron (III) nitrate nonahydrate and ammonium iron (III) citrate) were used, resulting in two different series of NPs, with Fe2O3 or Fe3O4 as a precursor, respectively. These different series (Co3O4(x% Fe2O3) NPs and Co3O4(x% Fe3O4) NPs) have different degrees of crystallinity, aggregation, Co/Fe ratio and spatial distributions of the metals in the NPs .
The particle size in ultra-pure water was measured with disc centrifuge. The particle size in cell culture medium (RPMI 1640, Gibco) with 25 mM Hepes and 2 mM L-Glutamine, 1% Penicilline-Streptomycine (Pen/Strep 10,000 U/mL, Glibco) and 10% heat inactivated Fetal Calf Serum (FCS, Glibco), was measured with dynamic light scattering (DLS). The redox activity was tested with electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) using a cell free system with a superoxide-selective spin-trap (tempone-H) to detect the generation of superoxide production and the spin trap DMPO  in combination with H2O2 and CuSO4 to analyse the capacity to scavenge hydroxyl free radicals. For the superoxide-selective spin-trap nanoparticle suspensions (0.56 mg/mL) were prepared and incubated with the spin-trap, Tempone-H (1 mM) immediately before the initial measurement. Samples were kept at 37 °C throughout and measurements were taken with an X-band EPR spectrometer (Magnettech MS-200, Berlin, Germany) at 60 min by drawing 50 μL of sample into a capillary tube (Scientific Laboratory Ltd., Coatbridge, UK) and sealing with a plug of soft sealant (Cristaseal, VWR International, UK). For the DMPO spin trap a sample was made of 12.5 μL nanoparticle suspension (1.28 mg/mL), 12.5 μL CuSO4 (20 μM), 25 μL H2O2 (0.5 M) and 50 μL DMPO (0.05 M). This sample was incubated in a shaker water bath at 37 °C for 15 min at 100 rpm, vortexed and taken up in a capillary tube, which was then sealed at the bottom with haematocrit and measured with the ESR Spectroscope (Miniscope MS 400; MT MagnetTech GmbH). All NPs were tested for endotoxin contamination using either a Limulus Amoebocyte Lysate Assay (chromogenic kinetic LAL assay) or LC-MS/MS determination .
Female BALB/c mice (~ 20 g body weight; 6–8 weeks old) were obtained from Charles River (Portage, MI). Mice were maintained at the Michigan State University (MSU) animal housing facilities at room temperature (21 °C–24 °C) and relative humidity of 45–70%, with a 12 h light/dark cycle. MSU is AAALAC accredited and all animal procedures & experimental protocols were approved by the MSU Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee.
Mice were lightly anesthetized for 1–2 min with 4% isoflurane in oxygen using an isoflurane vaporizer. Cradling the mouse in an upright position, the thumb was used to support the lower jaw and position the nose of the mouse so it was easily accessible. A volume of 30 μL was delivered to the tip of the nares. Once the instillate was fully inhaled, the mouse was placed back in its cage and monitored until conscious with normal respirations.
Necropsy, lavage collection and tissue preparation
Mice were anesthetized with an intraperitoneal injection of sodium pentobarbital (60 mg/kg body weight). A midline laparotomy was performed and approximately 0.5 mL of blood was drawn from the vena cava and collected in heparinized tubes (BD Microtainer, Franklin Lakes, NJ) for separation of plasma. The plasma was stored at − 80 °C for later biochemical analysis (OVA-specific IgE and IgG1). Animals were exsanguinated and the trachea was exposed and cannulated, and the heart and lungs were excised en bloc. A volume of 0.8 mL sterile saline was instilled through the tracheal cannula and withdrawn to recover bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF). A second intratracheal saline lavage was performed and the collected BALF was combined with the first sample for analysis.
After the BALF was collected, the left lung lobe was intratracheally fixed with neutral-buffered formalin at a constant pressure (30 cm H2O) for 2 h and then submersed in the same fixative for > 24 h until further tissue processing for light microscopy. Two sections were excised at the level of the 5th and 11th airway along the main axial airway (G5 and G11), to sample proximal and distal bronchiolar airways, respectively . Tissue was embedded in paraffin and 5- to 6-μm-thick sections were cut from the anterior surface. Lung sections were stained with hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) for routine light microscopic examination and with Alcian Blue (pH 2.5)/Periodic Acid–Schiff (AB/PAS) for identification of intraepithelial neutral and acidic mucosubstances in pulmonary bronchiolar epithelium. To detect eosinophils, slides were immunostained using a polyclonal rabbit antibody directed against murine eosinophil-specific major basic protein (MBP; 1:500; Mayo Clinic, AZ). Accumulations of B-lymphocytes in lung tissues were detected by immunohistochemical staining with rat anti-CD45R monoclonal (1:600; Becton Dickinson, Franklin Lakes, NJ, catalog # 550286).
OVA-specific IgE and IgG1 in plasma
Plasma was separated from blood and analysed for OVA-specific IgE and IgG1 using an ELISA kit (Cayman, Ann Arbor, MI) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. The plasma samples were diluted 8 times for the IgE and 1000 times for the IgG1 analysis.
The total number of cells in the BALF was determined using a hemocytometer. Cytological slides were prepared by centrifugation at 40 x g for 10 min at 20 °C using a Shandon cytospin 3 (Shandon Scientific, PA) and stained with Diff-Quick (Dade Behring, DE). Differential cell counts for neutrophils, eosinophils, macrophages/monocytes, and lymphocytes were assessed from a total of at least 200 cells. The remaining BALF was centrifuged at 240 x g for 15 min at 4 °C and the supernatant was collected and stored at − 80 °C for subsequent measurement of inflammatory cytokines (IFNγ, IL-4, IL-5, IL-1β, IL-6, IL-13, IL-17 and TNFα) using a Luminex-kit (Millipore, MA).
Histologic slides with lung tissue sections were scanned and digitized with a slide scanner (VS110, Olympus America, Center Valley, PA), and evaluated using stereological methods with newCAST software (VisioPharm, Hoersholm, Denmark). For quantification of major basic protein (MBP)-positive eosinophils, digitized images of the lung were selected as regions of interest and 40% of the lung tissue was captured at 400x magnification by systematic random sampling. Percentage of MBP-positive cells in the total lung tissue and in three discrete regions of 1) the parenchyma (alveoli and alveolar ducts), 2) perivascular and peribronchial interstitial spaces, and 3) other regions (inside blood vessels, bronchiole airspaces and pleura), were estimated using Stepanizer stereology software with a point grid by dividing the number of points hitting areas positive for MPB (a(p)positive) by the total number of points falling on all lung tissue (MBP-positive and –negative; a(p)reference tissue). For each region, percent density of eosinophils was calculated with the equation:
For quantification of CD45R-positive staining cells (the B-lymphocyte density), digitized images of G5 and G11 lung sections were selected as regions of interest and 40% of the lung tissue was captured at 400x magnification by systematic random sampling. Percentage of CD45R-positive cells in the perivascular and peribronchial interstitial spaces were estimated using Stepanizer stereology software using a point grid by dividing the number of points hitting areas positive for CD45R (a(p)positive) by the total number of points falling on all lung tissue (CD45R-positive and –negative; a(p)reference tissue). For each region, percent density of B-lymphocytes was calculated with the equation:
For quantification of AB/PAS-positive mucosubstances in the bronchiolar epithelium, all bronchiolar epithelium lining the main axial airway was selected and captured at 400x magnification. A point intercept grid was placed over the sampled images to estimate the density of mucosubstances per basal lamina. The number of points hitting AB/PAS-positive mucosubstances (Pm) was counted. The density of AB/PAS-positive mucosubstances (V̂m) was estimated by multiplying the total number of Pm by the area/point (a/p) and dividing them by the number of points hitting the reference space (n) as shown in the equation.
The surface density of the basal lamina (ŜBL) in the selected images was estimated by counting the number of intercepts (I) of the line probe with the basal lamina of the lateral wall divided by the length per point (l/p) and the number of points falling on the reference space (n) as described:
The positive density per basal lamina of the bronchiolar epithelium was then estimated by dividing V̂m by ŜBL.
GraphPad Prism v7.00 (GraphPad Software, San Diego, California, USA) was used to analyse the data. All data are depicted as group means ± standard deviation (SD). First, outliers were identified with Grubbs’ test (alpha = 0.05) and removed. The Shapiro-Wilk test and the Brown-Forsythe test were used to test for normality and equal variances, respectively. Differences between the OVA control group and a) the other control groups (PBS or TiO2 NP exposed), b) the CeO2 NP exposed groups, c) the Co3O4(x% Fe2O3) NP exposed groups and d) the Co3O4(x% Fe3O4) NPs exposed groups were analysed using a one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA), followed by a Dunnett’s post-hoc multiple comparisons test comparing groups exposed to OVA with NPs to groups exposed to OVA alone. For all statistical analyses, a p-value of ≤ 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
If the p-value of the Shapiro-Wilk or Brown-Forsythe test was ≤ 0.05, the data were log-normally transformed and again tested for normality and equal variances. If the p-values of the Shapiro-Wilk and Brown-Forsythe tests of the log-normally transformed data were > 0.05, a one-way ANOVA followed by a Dunnett’s post-hoc multiple comparisons test was performed on the log-normally transformed data. If the p-values of the Shapiro-Wilk test were still ≤ 0.05, a non-parametric (Kruskal Wallis) ANOVA was performed on the non-transformed data followed by a Dunn’s post-hoc multiple comparisons test.
Fe-doping had small, but not statistically significant, effects on NP size in suspension (Table 2). Other characteristics, such as shape and crystalline structure, did not significantly change with increasing amounts of doping. In Fig. 2, the redox activity of the NPs as measured in a cell free system by EPR using two different spin-traps are shown. EPR analysis using tempone-H demonstrated an increased capacity of Co3O4(25% Fe3O4) NPs to generate reactive superoxide free radicals compared to Co3O4(0 and 75% Fe3O4) NPs. Increasing amounts of Fe-doping using Fe3O4 led a significant decrease in scavenging capacity of Co3O4 NPs. Co3O4(0, 25 and 75% Fe2O3) NPs had a similar ROS generation and scavenging capacity (Fig. 2). Endotoxin levels were below the recommended endotoxin limits for preclinical research in animal models (5 EU/kg bw/day or 36 EU/mL for mice with a body weight of 30 g and a daily dose of 100 μL) .
OVA-specific IgE and IgG1 in plasma
OVA-specific IgE and IgG1 antibodies in plasma, indicating an OVA-specific immune response, were measured using an ELISA kit. OVA sensitization (0.02% OVA) and challenge (0.5% OVA) caused minimal, non-significant increases in plasma OVA-specific IgE and IgG1 compared to non-sensitized mice (phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) treated controls). Co-sensitization with NPs further increased the plasma OVA-specific IgE or IgG1 concentrations for all NPs. For all NPs, except for Co3O4(0 and 75% Fe3O4) NPs, the OVA-specific IgE and/or the IgG1 concentration was statistically significantly increased compared to OVA alone (Fig. 3).
BALF total cell count
The total and differential cell counts were determined using a hemocytometer and analysis of cytospin prepared slides. All mice sensitized with NP plus OVA showed a significant increase in total BALF cells compared to the OVA controls, indicating an increased inflammatory response, except for animals exposed to Co3O4(0% Fe2O3) NPs (p = 0.18; see Fig. 4a). For CeO2 NPs the total cell count increased with increasing amounts of Zr doping.
An increase in neutrophils in the BALF is indicative for a non-allergic, acute inflammatory response. No statistically significant differences between the percentage of neutrophils of the OVA controls and that of OVA plus NP exposed animals were observed, except for a decreased percentage of neutrophils in mice exposed to OVA plus CeO2(78% Zr) NPs, Co3O4(25 and 75% Fe2O3) NPs and Co3O4(75% Fe3O4) NPs. No major differences were observed between the different types of NPs (see Fig. 4b). The percentage of neutrophils decreased with the amount of doping for Zr-doped CeO2 NPs and Fe-doped Co3O4 NPs (using both Fe2O3 and Fe3O4).
Eosinophils and lymphocytes
The animals exposed to OVA plus CeO2 NPs showed a statistically significant increase in the percentage of eosinophils compared to the OVA controls (Fig. 4c), which is a typical feature of allergic asthma. For CeO2(27 and 78% Zr) NPs there was also a statistically significant increase in the percentage of lymphocytes (Fig. 4d), indicative for a chronic inflammatory response. Fe-doped Co3O4 NPs (using both Fe2O3 and Fe3O4) caused a statistically significant increase in the percentage of lymphocytes only, and not of eosinophils.
No major differences in the percentage of monocytes were observed between mice sensitized with NP plus OVA compared to the OVA controls (data not shown). More detailed data, including the absolute differential cell counts, can be found in Additional file 1.
The concentrations of several inflammatory cytokines in the BALF were determined in using a Luminex-kit specific for the various cytokines evaluated. Animals exposed to OVA plus CeO2 NPs showed increased concentrations of the Th2 cytokines IL-4 and IL-5 (but not IL-6 or IL-13) in the BALF compared to the OVA controls. Animals exposed to OVA plus most undoped and Fe-doped Co3O4 NPs showed increased concentrations of IL-6 compared to the OVA controls. All animals, including the controls (exposed to PBS, OVA and OVA plus TiO2 NPs during sensitization) had detectable concentrations of IL-13 (20–50 ng/mL) but these were not significantly different from one another (see Fig. 5d).
The concentrations of the other cytokines (IFNγ, IL-1β, IL-17 and TNFα) measured in BALF were either below the limits of detection or showed no significant changes in the OVA plus NP exposed groups compared to the OVA controls. More detailed data can be found in Additional file 2.
Mucous cell metaplasia
For quantification of epithelial mucous, lung tissue sections were stained with Alcian Blue/Periodic Acid Schiff (AB/PAS), a marker for neutral and acidic mucosubstances. Increased epithelial mucous production is a characteristic feature of allergic airway disease,
Sensitization and challenge with OVA caused a significant accumulation of intraepithelial mucosubstances (mucous cell metaplasia) in the epithelium lining the main proximal axial airways (G5), which was further enhanced by co-administration of OVA with TiO2 NPs (positive control). All CeO2 NPs enhanced mucosubstance accumulation; this was statistically significant for CeO2 NM212 and CeO2 with 27%, but not 78%, Zr doping (see Fig. 6).
By comparison, in the distal axial airways (G11), OVA sensitization and challenge did not affect epithelial accumulated mucosubstances. Co-sensitization with OVA plus TiO2 (positive control), CeO2 NM212, CeO2(0, 27 and 78% Zr), Co3O4(25% Fe2O3) and Co3O4(25% Fe3O4) NPs led to a statistically significant increase in mucosubstances compared to the OVA controls.
For quantification of the eosinophil density, a biomarker for an allergic airway response, lung tissue sections were stained for murine major basic protein (MBP), a specific marker for eosinophils.
Parenchymal lung tissue
OVA sensitization and challenge did not increase the overall eosinophil density in the pulmonary parenchyma compared to non-sensitized mice (PBS controls). Co-sensitization of OVA with TiO2 (positive control) and CeO2 NPs significantly increased eosinophil density compared to OVA alone. This increase was statistically significant in all these groups, except for the OVA plus CeO2 NM212 NPs group. Co-sensitization of OVA with undoped and doped Co3O4 NPs had no effect on eosinophil density (Fig. 7a).
Perivascular and peribronchial lung tissue
OVA sensitization and challenge did not significantly affect the eosinophil density in the peribronchial and perivascular region of the lung compared to non-sensitized mice (PBS controls). Co-sensitization of OVA with TiO2 (positive control), CeO2(0, 27 and 78% Zr) and Co3O4(25 and 75% Fe3O4) NPs caused significant increases in eosinophil density compared to OVA alone (Fig. 7b).
OVA sensitization and challenge did not significantly alter the overall pulmonary eosinophil density compared to non-sensitized mice (PBS controls). Co-sensitization of OVA with TiO2 NPs (positive control), CeO2(0 and 78% Zr) and Co3O4(25 and 75% Fe3O4) NPs caused significant increases in eosinophil density compared to OVA alone (Fig. 7c).
For quantification of the B-lymphocytes density lung tissue sections were stained for CD45R, a marker for B-lymphocytes.
Co-sensitization with OVA and Co3O4 NPs induced a severe accumulation of B-lymphocytes (CD45+ cells) in the perivascular/peribronchiolar interstitium, indicative for a chronic inflammatory response. By comparison, accumulation of B-lymphocytes in lungs from OVA plus CeO2 NP-sensitised mice was not as evident (Fig. 8).
Examples of histopathological findings in the scanned and digitized histologic slides of the lung tissue sections are shown in Figs. 9 and 10. No exposure related microscopically observable lung lesions were found in the PBS control group (Fig. 9a and b). All mice that were intranasally sensitized and challenged with OVA (OVA controls) had some degree of histopathology in the lung that was characteristic of allergic airway disease. This histopathology consisted of a mixed inflammatory cell influx containing eosinophils, lymphoid cells (lymphocytes and plasma cells) and, to a lesser extent, neutrophils in the interstitial tissue surrounding blood vessels and conducting airways (perivascular and peribronchiolar inflammation) (most conspicuous in G5, see Fig. 9c, but also in G11). Associated with these inflammatory lesions, there was mucous cell metaplasia of the airway epithelium (appearance of mucous cells with AB/PAS-stained mucosubstances) (see Fig. 9d).
Mice co-exposed to OVA and NPs had a mild to moderate multifocal accumulation of particle-laden, hypertrophic macrophages in alveolar air spaces (most conspicuous in centriacinar regions of the lung) and more severe inflammatory or epithelial lung lesions compared to mice exposed to OVA alone. Mice co-exposed to OVA and TiO2, CeO2 NM212, or Zr-doped CeO2 NPs had more severe lymphocytic and eosinophilic inflammation as (see Fig. 9e) as well as more severe mucous cell metaplasia (most conspicuous in G11, see Fig. 9f) compared to the OVA-alone treated mice (see Fig. 9c and d).
In contrast, OVA and Co3O4(with or without Fe-doping) co-exposed mice did not have more severe eosinophilic inflammation or mucous cell metaplasia as compared to OVA-alone treated mice. Interestingly, these OVA and Co3O4 co-exposed mice exhibited more severe perivascular or peribronchiolar lymphoid cell accumulation compared to mice co-exposed to the other NPs, organized in ectopic lymphoid-like structures (ELS, see Fig. 10a, b and c). ELS are tertiary lymphoid organs, associated for example with infections and autoimmune diseases, that develop in areas of chronic inflammation and are characterized by the formation of organized B- and T-cell aggregates and germinal centres with follicular dendritic cell networks [23, 24]. These lung lesions were also observed in mice co-exposed to OVA and Co3O4 with Fe-doping (using both Fe2O3 and Fe3O4, see Fig. 10d, e and f).
All NPs investigated possessed adjuvant activity, leading to changes in OVA-specific IgE and IgG1 plasma levels, differential cell count and cytokines in BALF, and histopathological detection of mucosa cell metaplasia and eosinophil density in the conducting airways. Co-exposure of OVA and Co3O4 NPs also induced perivascular and peribronchiolar lymphoid cell accumulation and the formation of ELS in lungs.
Although the increased OVA-specific IgE and IgG1 plasma levels of all OVA + NP exposed groups compared to OVA controls were not statistically significant for all NPs, they do indicate that NPs have the capacity to enhance allergic sensitisation in mice. This is supported by the increases in eosinophils, lymphocytes, IL-4, IL-5 and IL-6 in BALF after co-exposure of OVA and many NPs compared to the OVA controls. In our previous study, we found that SiO2 and TiO2 NP exposure alone (without OVA) during the induction phase did not lead to an increase in OVA-specific IgE and IgG1 plasma levels or eosinophils in BALF after OVA challenge [9, 10]. These findings suggest that the allergic response can only be enhanced via co-exposure of the allergen and NPs, and not by exposure to NPs alone. In the current study, all NPs were only tested in combination with OVA, and the results show that all NPs were able to act as adjuvant, albeit to varying degrees.
The influence of the chemical composition
The differences in OVA-specific IgE and IgG1 plasma levels of the animals co-sensitized to OVA and the different NPs indicate that the chemical composition of the NPs influences their potency to exacerbate allergic airway sensitization. The relative adjuvant potencies of the different NPs varied with the different biomarkers of effects (Fig. 11), indicating that the chemical composition also influences the type of the allergic response.
Type of the immune responses
Animals co-exposed to OVA and undoped CeO2 NPs showed higher OVA-specific IgE plasma levels compared to animals co-exposed to OVA and the other undoped NPs (TiO2 NPs, CeO2 NM212 NPs, and Co3O4 NPs), indicative for a type 1 (immediate or IgE mediated) allergic response. Additionally, indications for a Th2 type immune response were observed, characterised by an increase in the percentage of eosinophils and increased concentrations of the Th2 cytokines IL-4 and IL-5 (but not IL-13) in the BALF. Animals co-exposed to OVA and the OECD representative manufactured nanomaterial CeO2 (NM212), also showed some indications of a Th2 type response, albeit less marked than those observed in animals co-exposed to OVA and CeO2(0% Zr) NPs: plasma OVA-specific IgE levels, percentage of eosinophils in BALF and BALF IL-4 concentrations were much lower in animals co-exposed to OVA and CeO2 NM212 than in animals co-exposed to OVA and CeO2(0% Zr) NPs. In contrast, concentrations of IL-5 in BALF were similarly affected by both forms of CeO2. These findings are in line with a previous in vivo study in which CeO2 NPs induced increased antigen specific IgE levels, eosinophils, Th2 cytokines and Th2 chemokines when co-exposed with house dust mite  and an in vitro study in which CeO2 NPs exposure of human dendritic cells induced a Th2-dominated cell profile .
Co-exposure to OVA and undoped Co3O4 NPs also showed responses indicative of a type 1 allergic response, albeit, the OVA-specific IgE plasma levels were lower compared to co-exposure to OVA and the CeO2(0% Zr) NPs. Furthermore, the response after co-exposure to OVA and Co3O4 NPs was characterised by no or less marked increases in in BALF IL-4 and IL-5 concentrations and the percentage of eosinophils in BALF, but a more pronounced increase in the BALF IL-6 concentration and the percentage of lymphocytes in BALF compared to co-exposure to OVA and the CeO2(0% Zr) NPs. This pattern of response is in line with a previous in vivo study in C57Bl/6 mice in which subcutaneous administration of Co3O4 NPs with OVA induced both Th1 and Th2 type responses . Several biomarkers, including the OVA-specific IgG1 plasma levels and IL-6 concentrations in the BALF, were remarkably different in animals co-exposed to OVA and the two different types of undoped Co3O4 NPs, indicating that not only chemical composition, but also other physicochemical characteristics of the NPs are of influence to the allergic response. Although, the production process of the two undoped Co3O4 NPs was the same, they differed in the degree of crystallinity, aggregation, Co/Fe ratio and spatial distributions of the metals in the NPs .
The immune response after co-exposure to OVA and TiO2 NPs was indicative for a Th2 immune response, characterised by an increase in eosinophils, IL-4 and IL-5 in BALF. Previous studies with TiO2 NPs have found contradictory results regarding effects on immune responses. Schanen et al.  found that exposure of dendritic cells to TiO2 NPs led towards Th1-based responses, while Vandebriel et al.  and de Haar et al.  observed Th2 type immune responses in mice after co-exposure to OVA plus TiO2 NPs. However, the contradictory result may have been caused by differences in the physicochemical characteristics (e.g. sizes and/or crystallinity) of the TiO2 NPs used in the studies by Schanen et al.  and de Haar et al. , compared to the TiO2 NPs used in our study, which were the same TiO2 NPs as Vandebriel et al. . Although this study adds weight to the steering of the immune response towards a Th2 response by TiO2 NP co-exposure with antigens, more studies which measure a wide range of Th2 and Th1/Th17 associated biomarkers are needed to gain more insight in the type of adjuvant activity associated with by TiO2 NPs exposure.
Lung morphology and ectopic lymphoid-like structures
Animals co-exposed to OVA and TiO2, CeO2 NM212, or CeO2(0% Zr) NPs had more severe mucous cell metaplasia (most conspicuous in G11, but also in G5), as well as more severe eosinophilic inflammation, compared to the OVA-alone treated mice. OVA and Co3O4 co-exposed mice showed more severe perivascular and peribronchiolar lymphoid cell accumulation, organized into ELS. These findings were accompanied by an increase in lymphocytes in BALF. In mice broncho-associated lymphoid tissue (BALT) is usually absent, however, it can be induced (inducible BALT or iBALT) by inflammatory processes and infections . In humans, iBALT formation can be observed in the lung in response to various types of infectious and inflammatory states, caused by infectious organisms, diesel exhaust, cigarette smoke silica, and various autoimmune diseases [30, 31]. In previous studies lymphocyte foci or aggregates have been observed in lungs of rats after intratracheal instillation of Co3O4 NPs , as well as in lungs of mice after intranasal exposure to OVA , crystalline silica particles (1.5–2.0 μm)  and after inhalation of CdO NPs . However, the role of iBALT in the pathophysiology of chronic allergic diseases, such as asthma, is poorly understood [30, 31]. Studies investigating whether or not iBALT is involved in the development or progression of allergy or asthma showed conflicting results and the pathways that control the development and function of iBALT are poorly understood.
The influence of redox modification by doping
The differences in immune responses observed between the groups exposed to the same type of NPs, but different amounts of doping (Zr-doping for CeO2 NPs and Fe-doping for Co3O4 NPs), indicate that redox modification can influence the adjuvant activity of NPs. However, the amount of doping did not always show a clear trend in the response of the different biomarkers of effects. Some biomarkers indicated that the undoped NPs exhibit most adjuvant activity, while other biomarkers indicated that either the NP with the lowest amount of doping or the NPs with the highest amount of doping exhibited most adjuvant activity. Additionally, most biomarkers of effects neither decreased nor increased with greater degrees of doping (see in Additional file 3).
This lack of trend between increasing amounts of doping and the biomarkers of effects is also observed in the EPR data, in which only the Co3O4(0, 25 and 75% Fe3O4) NPs showed a decreasing scavenging capacity with increasing amounts of doping (see Fig. 2). This decrease in free hydroxyl radical scavenging capacity was unexpected based on the Ec levels of Co3O4 and Fe3O4. We expected that doping using Fe3O4 would increase, rather than decrease the ability of Co3O4 to scavenge free hydroxyl radicals, because the Ec level of Co3O4 overlaps with the cellular redox potential, whereas that of Fe3O4 does not. On the other hand, the superoxide generation did increase with Fe-doping of Co3O4 NPs using 25% Fe3O4, but this ROS generation was not further increased with increasing amounts of Fe-doping. It is possible that differences in particle size and aggregation counterbalanced any doping-related differences in free radical generation or scavenging [11, 36], as the particle size in water as measured with disc centrifuge was larger for the Co3O4(75% Fe3O4) NPs compared to Co3O4(25% Fe3O4) NPs, although the difference in particle size between these two NPs was relatively small. Nonetheless, we would still have expected more notable differences in free radical generation from the surfaces of the differently doped materials. Physicochemical characterisation of the materials indicates successful incorporation of the doping into the crystal structure of the NP , thus at present we can only speculate as to the reason for the limited effect of doping on free radical generation.
Since, the amount of doping or band gap energy of the NPs were not predictive for adjuvant activity or the ability to generate or scavenge specific radical, we also investigated if the ability of the NPs to generate or scavenge specific radicals was predictive for the adjuvant activity.
The superoxide generation as measured with the EPR was not predictive for the adjuvant activity. Only a few biomarkers of effects decreased with decreasing amounts of superoxide generation and these biomarkers of effects were different for each of the NP series (see arrows in Fig. 12).
The scavenging capacity as measured with the EPR was also not predictive for the adjuvant activity. Only a few biomarkers of effects decreased with increasing amounts of scavenging capacity and these biomarkers of effects were different for each of the NP series (see arrows in Fig. 13).
While EPR is a useful technique to predict the ability of NPs to generate cellular oxidative stress, this acellular approach provides only a facet of the redox reactivity of NPs within cellular compartments. However, due to the number of NPs under investigation, a comprehensive comparison of redox activity in cellular assays was not possible within the current study. Therefore, a possible explanation for the lack of trend between the EPR results and the adjuvant activity is that redox activity of the NPs may change due to interaction with the physiological environment, e.g. by corona formation, aggregation, elimination, redox reactions, etc. Interactions with the physiological environment are known to influence the reactivity, cellular uptake and toxicity of the NPs [37,38,39,40]. Han et al.  found that co-exposure of OVA and polyethylene glycol-conjugated (PEGylated) SiO2 NPs induced less severe airway inflammation compared to non-coated SiO2 NPs. It was suggested that this was due to an increased aggregation of the PEGylated SiO2 NPs in saline compared to the non-coated SiO2. However, the small differences in the (aggregated) particle diameter of the NPs in water observed in our study (see Table 2) would be very unlikely to significantly influence adjuvant potency. Larger differences in the (aggregated) particle diameter of the NPs were observed in a more physiologically relevant environment (i.e. buffered cell culture medium with proteins from fetal calf serum) (see Table 2). However, no relation between these differences in aggregated size and the adjuvant potencies of the different NPs found. Horie et al.  found differences in OVA-specific IgE and IgG1 concentrations in the blood of mice exposed to ZnO compared to SiO2-coated ZnO NPs after subsequent exposure to OVA. The investigators suggested that these differences might be due to differences in solubility and continuous Zn2+ release from the NPs. Although the NPs in our study are expected to be relatively insoluble, further evaluation of the possible degradation and ion release under various physiological conditions (e.g. in lysosomal fluid) are needed to rule out this possibility. Further research is needed to better understand the mechanisms of the adjuvant activity of NPs, including the influence of the NP properties and NP interactions with their physiological environment, including allergens (such as OVA), on the adjuvant activity.
The chemical composition of NPs in this study influenced both their relative potency to exacerbate allergic airway sensitization to ovalbumin (OVA), and the type of the immune response. The adjuvant activity of CeO2 NPs seems to be primarily mediated via a Th2-type immune response, whereas the adjuvant activity of Co3O4 NPs was characterised by no or less marked increases in OVA-specific IgE plasma levels, BALF IL-4 and IL-5 concentrations and percentages of eosinophils in BALF and more pronounced increases in the BALF IL-6 concentrations and percentages of lymphocytes in BALF. Co-exposure to OVA and Co3O4 NPs also induced lymphoid cell accumulation and the formation of ectopic lymphoid tissues in the lungs. No relation between the acellular redox potential and the observed adjuvant activity of the different of NPs was found, suggesting that acellular ROS assays may not be suitable to predict adjuvant capacity. These findings highlight the complexity of biological interplay between different NP species and the need for additional data and methods to formulate scenarios that better predict the adjuvant activity of nanomaterial families.
Availability of data and materials
The datasets used and/or analysed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Analysis of variance
Bronchoalveolar Lavage Fluid
Conduction band energy level
Electron Paramagnetic Resonance
Limulus Amoebocyte Lysate
Major Basic Protein
Reactive Oxygen Species
Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy
Cho WS, Duffin R, Thielbeer F, Bradley M, Megson IL, Macnee W, Poland CA, Tran CL, Donaldson K. Zeta potential and solubility to toxic ions as mechanisms of lung inflammation caused by metal/metal oxide nanoparticles. Toxicol Sci. 2012;126:469–77.
Dekkers S, Oomen AG, Bleeker EA, Vandebriel RJ, Micheletti C, Cabellos J, Janer G, Fuentes N, Vazquez-Campos S, Borges T, et al. Towards a nanospecific approach for risk assessment. Regul Toxicol Pharmacol. 2016;80:46–59.
Teunenbroek TV, Baker J, Dijkzeul A. Towards a more effective and efficient governance and regulation of nanomaterials. Part Fibre Toxicol. 2017;14:54.
Zhang H, Ji Z, Xia T, Meng H, Low-Kam C, Liu R, Pokhrel S, Lin S, Wang X, Liao YP, et al. Use of metal oxide nanoparticle band gap to develop a predictive paradigm for oxidative stress and acute pulmonary inflammation. ACS Nano. 2012;6:4349–68.
Miller MR, Shaw CA, Langrish JP. From particles to patients: oxidative stress and the cardiovascular effects of air pollution. Futur Cardiol. 2012;8:577–602.
Unfried K, Catrin A, Lars-Oliver K, Anna VM, Susanne G-B, Schins Roel PF. Cellular responses to nanoparticles: target structures and mechanisms. Nanotoxicology. 2007;1:52–71.
Meldrum K, Guo C, Marczylo EL, Gant TW, Smith R, Leonard MO. Mechanistic insight into the impact of nanomaterials on asthma and allergic airway disease. Part Fibre Toxicol. 2017;14:45.
Pisoschi AM, Pop A. The role of antioxidants in the chemistry of oxidative stress: a review. Eur J Med Chem. 2015;97:55–74.
Brandenberger C, Rowley NL, Jackson-Humbles DN, Zhang Q, Bramble LA, Lewandowski RP, Wagner JG, Chen W, Kaplan BL, Kaminski NE, et al. Engineered silica nanoparticles act as adjuvants to enhance allergic airway disease in mice. Part Fibre Toxicol. 2013;10:26.
Vandebriel RJ, Vermeulen JP, van Engelen LB, de Jong B, Verhagen LM, de la Fonteyne-Blankestijn LJ, Hoonakker ME, de Jong WH. The crystal structure of titanium dioxide nanoparticles influences immune activity in vitro and in vivo. Part Fibre Toxicol. 2018;15:9.
Fu PP, Xia Q, Hwang HM, Ray PC, Yu H. Mechanisms of nanotoxicity: generation of reactive oxygen species. J Food Drug Anal. 2014;22:64–75.
Khanna P, Ong C, Bay BH, Baeg GH. Nanotoxicity: an interplay of oxidative stress, inflammation and cell death. Nanomaterials (Basel). 2015;5:1163–80.
Nel A, Xia T, Madler L, Li N. Toxic potential of materials at the nanolevel. Science. 2006;311:622–7.
Dekkers S, Miller MR, Schins RPF, Romer I, Russ M, Vandebriel RJ, Lynch I, Belinga-Desaunay MF, Valsami-Jones E, Connell SP, et al. The effect of zirconium doping of cerium dioxide nanoparticles on pulmonary and cardiovascular toxicity and biodistribution in mice after inhalation. Nanotoxicology. 2017;11:794–808.
Zhang H, Pokhrel S, Ji Z, Meng H, Wang X, Lin S, Chang CH, Li L, Li R, Sun B, et al. PdO doping tunes band-gap energy levels as well as oxidative stress responses to a co (3) O (4) p-type semiconductor in cells and the lung. J Am Chem Soc. 2014;136:6406–20.
Kroker M, Sydlik U, Autengruber A, Cavelius C, Weighardt H, Kraegeloh A, Unfried K. Preventing carbon nanoparticle-induced lung inflammation reduces antigen-specific sensitization and subsequent allergic reactions in a mouse model. Part Fibre Toxicol. 2015;12:20.
Cabanas A, Darr JA, L E, Poliakoff M. A continous and clean one-step synthesis of nano-particulate Ce1-xZrxO2 solid solutions in near-critical water. Chem Comm. 2000;2000:901–2.
Liu J, Römer I, Tang SVY, Valsami-Jones E, Palmer RE. Crystallinity depends on choice of iron salt precursor in the continous hydrothermal synthesis of Fe-co oxide nanoparticles. RSC Adv. 2017;7:37436–40.
He W, Liu Y, Wamer WG, Yin JJ. Electron spin resonance spectroscopy for the study of nanomaterial-mediated generation of reactive oxygen species. J Food Drug Anal. 2014;22:49–63.
Giannakou C, Aimonen K, Bloois LV, Catalan J, Geertsma RE, Gremmer ER, de Jong WH, Keizers PH, Schwillens PL, Vandebriel RJ, Park MV. Sensitive method for endotoxin determination in nanomedicinal product samples. Nanomedicine (Lond). 2019;14:1231–46.
Harkema JR, Hotchkiss JA. In vivo effects of endotoxin on intraepithelial mucosubstances in rat pulmonary airways. Quantitative histochemistry. Am J Pathol. 1992;141:307–17.
Malyala P, Singh M. Endotoxin limits in formulations for preclinical research. J Pharm Sci. 2008;97:2041–4.
Carragher DM, Rangel-Moreno J, Randall TD. Ectopic lymphoid tissues and local immunity. Semin Immunol. 2008;20:26–42.
Pitzalis C, Jones GW, Bombardieri M, Jones SA. Ectopic lymphoid-like structures in infection, cancer and autoimmunity. Nat Rev Immunol. 2014;14:447–62.
Meldrum K, Robertson SB, Romer I, Marczylo T, Dean LSN, Rogers A, Gant TW, Smith R, Tetley TD, Leonard MO. Cerium dioxide nanoparticles exacerbate house dust mite induced type II airway inflammation. Part Fibre Toxicol. 2018;15:24.
Schanen BC, Das S, Reilly CM, Warren WL, Self WT, Seal S, Drake DR 3rd. Immunomodulation and T helper TH (1)/TH (2) response polarization by CeO (2) and TiO (2) nanoparticles. PLoS One. 2013;8:e62816.
Cho WS, Dart K, Nowakowska DJ, Zheng X, Donaldson K, Howie SE. Adjuvanticity and toxicity of cobalt oxide nanoparticles as an alternative vaccine adjuvant. Nanomedicine (Lond). 2012;7:1495–505.
de Haar C, Hassing I, Bol M, Bleumink R, Pieters R. Ultrafine but not fine particulate matter causes airway inflammation and allergic airway sensitization to co-administered antigen in mice. Clin Exp Allergy. 2006;36:1469–79.
Randall TD. Bronchus-associated lymphoid tissue (BALT) structure and function. Adv Immunol. 2010;107:187–241.
Hirahara K, Shinoda K, Endo Y, Ichikawa T, Nakayama T. Maintenance of memory-type pathogenic Th2 cells in the pathophysiology of chronic airway inflammation. Inflamm Regen. 2018;38:10.
Hwang JY, Randall TD, Silva-Sanchez A. Inducible bronchus-associated lymphoid tissue: taming inflammation in the lung. Front Immunol. 2016;7:258.
Cho WS, Duffin R, Bradley M, Megson IL, Macnee W, Howie SE, Donaldson K. NiO and Co3O4 nanoparticles induce lung DTH-like responses and alveolar lipoproteinosis. Eur Respir J. 2012;39:546–57.
Guest IC, Sell S. Bronchial lesions of mouse model of asthma are preceded by immune complex vasculitis and induced bronchial associated lymphoid tissue (iBALT). Lab Investig. 2015;95:886–902.
Bates MA, Brandenberger C, Langohr I, Kumagai K, Harkema JR, Holian A, Pestka JJ. Silica triggers inflammation and ectopic lymphoid Neogenesis in the lungs in parallel with accelerated onset of systemic autoimmunity and glomerulonephritis in the lupus-prone NZBWF1 mouse. PLoS One. 2015;10:e0125481.
Blum JL, Rosenblum LK, Grunig G, Beasley MB, Xiong JQ, Zelikoff JT. Short-term inhalation of cadmium oxide nanoparticles alters pulmonary dynamics associated with lung injury, inflammation, and repair in a mouse model. Inhal Toxicol. 2014;26:48–58.
Hsieh SF, Bello D, Schmidt DF, Pal AK, Stella A, Isaacs JA, Rogers EJ. Mapping the biological oxidative damage of engineered nanomaterials. Small. 2013;9:1853–65.
Ahsan SM, Rao CM, Ahmad MF. Nanoparticle-protein interaction: the significance and role of protein Corona. Adv Exp Med Biol. 2018;1048:175–98.
Barbero F, Russo L, Vitali M, Piella J, Salvo I, Borrajo ML, Busquets-Fite M, Grandori R, Bastus NG, Casals E, Puntes V. Formation of the protein Corona: the Interface between nanoparticles and the immune system. Semin Immunol. 2017;34:52–60.
Saptarshi SR, Duschl A, Lopata AL. Interaction of nanoparticles with proteins: relation to bio-reactivity of the nanoparticle. J Nanobiotechnology. 2013;11:26.
Shannahan JH, Brown JM. Engineered nanomaterial exposure and the risk of allergic disease. Curr Opin Allergy Clin Immunol. 2014;14:95–9.
Han H, Park YH, Park HJ, Lee K, Um K, Park JW, Lee JH. Toxic and adjuvant effects of silica nanoparticles on ovalbumin-induced allergic airway inflammation in mice. Respir Res. 2016;17:60.
Horie M, Stowe M, Tabei M, Kuroda E. Pharyngeal aspiration of metal oxide nanoparticles showed potential of allergy aggravation effect to inhaled ovalbumin. Inhal Toxicol. 2015;27:181–90.
The authors would like to thank Ryan Lewandowski and Amy Freeland of MSU for their help during the conduction of the animal experiment and valuable technical assistance, Amy Porter, Kathleen Joseph and William Lienhart of MSU Investigative Histopathology Laboratory for their histotechnology support, Daan Leseman and Eric Gremmer of RIVM for their support in the characterizing the particles and for the IgG and IgE ELISA and cytokine analyses of the BALF, respectively, Ed Lester of Promethean Particles for his contribution to the design and production of the particles, Christina Giannakou of RIVM for the LCMS-MS analysis of the endotoxin levels, and Eva Valsami-Jones of UoB coordinator of the NanoMILE project.
The work leading to these results has received funding from the European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme for research, technology development and demonstration under grant agreement n° 310451 (NanoMILE) and the Netherlands Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority (V090016) (NVWA). MRM is supported by a British Heart Foundation (BHF) Special Project Grant (SP/15/8/31575).
Ethics approval and consent to participate
All animal procedures and experimental protocols were approved by the MSU Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee.
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Total and differential cell counts in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid.
Cytokines in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid.
The influence of the ability of NPs to induce superoxide generation as measured in an acellular EPR assay on the different biomarkers of effects.
About this article
Cite this article
Dekkers, S., Wagner, J.G., Vandebriel, R.J. et al. Role of chemical composition and redox modification of poorly soluble nanomaterials on their ability to enhance allergic airway sensitisation in mice. Part Fibre Toxicol 16, 39 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12989-019-0320-6